IELTS Clinic
What this practice is, and is not
Practice with original material, not an official IELTS paper. Scores are raw practice marks and estimates from the public criteria; only an IELTS test gives you a band.
IELTS Clinic · Reading
YES/NO/NOT GIVEN: whose claim is it?
When to use it, and the rule
Use this when: Two or more misses tagged writer-view in one set, or any YNNG item answered from a reported view.
YES/NO/NOT GIVEN asks what the writer believes, not what is true in the world and not what other people in the text believe. Reported views (‘Critics argue …’, ‘It is often said …’, ‘Supporters claim …’) belong to those people unless the writer agrees with them. Find the writer's voice: I or we, in my view, evaluative words (illusory, promising, persuasive, flawed), concessions (the writer usually stands on the side after although, but or yet) and the strength of the claim (may, probably, not necessarily). If the writer reports a view and takes no side, a statement about the writer's opinion is NOT GIVEN.
A worked example
BeforeText: ‘Some economists claim that a four-day working week raises productivity. The evidence so far comes mainly from firms that volunteered for trials, and such firms may have been unusually well suited to the change. I am not yet persuaded that the results would hold across the wider economy.’ Statement: The writer is convinced that a four-day week would raise productivity in most workplaces. Learner's answer: YES, ‘because the text says it raises productivity’.
AfterNO. ‘Raises productivity’ is the economists' claim, introduced by ‘Some economists claim’. The writer's own view is ‘I am not yet persuaded that the results would hold across the wider economy’, which contradicts ‘convinced … in most workplaces’.
The learner matched words from a reported view. In YNNG, first ask whose sentence the evidence is. The writer's hedging (‘may have been unusually well suited’) and ‘not yet persuaded’ show doubt, which contradicts ‘convinced’.
Drill 1
Text: ‘Critics argue that museum entry charges deter poorer visitors. The museum's own figures are not broken down by income, so they can neither confirm nor refute this claim.’ Statement: The writer agrees that entry charges deter poorer visitors.
Drill 2
Text: ‘It is often said that taking notes by hand improves memory. The studies I have reviewed suggest a modest benefit at best, and several find none.’ Statement: The writer thinks that taking notes by hand has a large effect on memory.
Drill 3
Text: ‘Remote work has real costs for new employees, who learn a great deal from overhearing colleagues. That said, I see no reason to think these costs cannot be reduced by deliberate mentoring.’ Statement: The writer believes that the disadvantages of remote work for new employees can be lessened.