IELTS preparation · Writing

IELTS Clinic

What this practice is, and is not

Practice with original material, not an official IELTS paper. Scores are raw practice marks and estimates from the public criteria; only an IELTS test gives you a band.

IELTS Clinic · Writing

Unclear position or a missing part of the question (Task 2)

When to use it, and the rule

Use this when: Task 2 where the position appears only in the conclusion, changes during the essay, or one part of a two-part question gets less than a quarter of the body; TR estimated at 6 or below.

Before planning, underline three things: the topic, the precise focus (words such as 'legally required', 'whenever', 'outweigh', 'positive or negative') and the instruction. Count the parts: two questions need two answers, and 'discuss both views and give your opinion' needs three things. Then write a one-sentence answer to each part; these sentences become your introduction and your topic sentences. A position can be partial ('I agree up to a point...') as long as it says exactly where the line falls and stays the same from introduction to conclusion. 'In this essay I will discuss...' is not a position. At band 8, the position engages with the exact wording of the question, not just its topic.

A worked example

BeforeOnline reviews are very popular today. There are many advantages and disadvantages of online reviews. In this essay I will discuss them.

AfterOnline reviews have become influential mainly because they seem to offer the honest judgement of ordinary customers at the moment a decision is made. On the whole, I think this is a positive development, provided readers treat reviews as one source of evidence rather than the final word.

The prompt asks two questions: why reviews have become influential, and whether this is positive or negative. The 'before' introduction answers neither and turns the second question into a list of advantages and disadvantages. The 'after' version answers both questions directly, and its condition ('provided readers...') sets up a body paragraph.

Drill 1

Identify every part of this question and write a one-sentence answer to each: 'Supermarkets and other shops are increasingly replacing staffed tills with self-service checkouts. How does this change affect customers? What effects might it have on employment?'

Drill 2

The position drifts. Fix it so the introduction and conclusion agree. Introduction: 'I completely agree that cities should ban cars from their centres.' Conclusion: 'In conclusion, both sides have advantages and it depends on the city.'

Drill 3

This thesis answers the topic, not the question. Rewrite it. Question: 'Some people think that employers should be legally required to let staff work from home whenever their job can be done remotely. To what extent do you agree or disagree?' Thesis: 'Working from home has many advantages and disadvantages.'