Lesson
Modals: distinguish possibility, advice and obligation
Goal: Choose modal meanings that fit the evidence or rule · Distinguish prohibition from absence of obligation · Build accurate modal verb phrases in present and past contexts · Keep recommendations clear while qualifying uncertain outcomes
- Modal verbs show how a speaker treats an action or claim. May, might and could can mark a particular possibility; can often describes general ability or what is possible in some circumstances. 'Online lessons can widen access' describes a general potential, while 'This new course might attract more rural learners' predicts one uncertain outcome. Do not assign fixed percentages to may, might and could: context matters, and more than one can be appropriate.
- Obligation is different from possibility. Must and have to can both express a requirement, while should usually presents advice or a recommendation. The negatives are especially important: 'Visitors must not enter' prohibits entry, whereas 'Visitors do not have to enter' makes entry unnecessary. A policy argument should distinguish what is required, recommended, permitted or merely possible. A stronger modal is not automatically a stronger argument if the stated facts cannot support it.
- Use a base verb after a modal: may improve, should provide, must be checked. Do not add -s or to after should, may or must. To describe a past requirement, use had to: 'Staff had to leave when the alarm sounded'. Must have + participle usually expresses a conclusion about the past, not a past duty: 'The tutor must have left' is an inference. In Task 1, report shown facts directly and leave out unsupported guesses about motives or causes.
A worked example
BeforeThe centre should to stay open later. This must increase attendance. Visitors must not book because booking is optional.
AfterThe centre should stay open later. This might increase attendance among people who work late. Visitors do not have to book because booking is optional.
Should takes the base verb without to. Might marks an uncertain benefit and identifies a plausible group. Do not have to expresses optional booking; must not would incorrectly prohibit booking.
Use it elsewhere
Highlight the modal phrases in one Task 2 essay and one formal letter. Label each meaning, repair any must not / do not have to confusion, and replace one unsupported certainty with a specific, limited claim.