Lesson
Test the writer's claim: YES, NO or NOT GIVEN
Goal: Match a statement to the writer's actual view in Academic Reading · Distinguish contradiction from missing information · Preserve limits such as some, only, may and unless · Keep a reported opinion separate from the writer's judgement
- YES/NO/NOT GIVEN is an Academic Reading task about the writer's views or claims. YES means the statement agrees with that view, NO means it contradicts it, and NOT GIVEN means the passage does not establish agreement or contradiction. Do not substitute TRUE/FALSE labels. General Training Reading does not use this task type; its information-identification practice belongs to TRUE/FALSE/NOT GIVEN.
- Break each statement into the person or thing, the claim, and any limit: who, when, how much, or under what condition. A passage may mention both training and costs without saying training reduced costs. That missing relationship is NOT GIVEN. By contrast, 'training raised costs' directly conflicts with 'training reduced costs' and supports NO.
- The writer may report a view without adopting it. Read beyond 'some critics argue' to see whether the writer agrees, rejects the view or leaves it open. Use only passage evidence: your own experience cannot settle an unstated comparison. For a 6.5 target, practise explaining exactly which part of a statement is supported, contradicted or missing; repeated topic words alone are insufficient.
A worked example
BeforePassage: 'The flexible timetable improved attendance among trainees with long journeys. The report did not compare examination results.' Statement: 'The flexible timetable improved examination results.' Answer: NO, because better results are not mentioned.
AfterAnswer: NOT GIVEN. Attendance improved, but the effect on examination results is not established.
'Improved attendance' concerns attendance, not examination performance. 'Did not compare examination results' identifies the missing evidence; it does not say results stayed the same or became worse.
Use it elsewhere
Use a fresh Academic passage containing this question type. For each wrong answer, write a short evidence note: 'opposite stated' or 'claim not settled'. Practise new statements rather than memorising the examples; do not invent a fixed score-to-band conversion from this lesson.