IELTS notebook · Band 7.5 · Learn · Reading

Lesson 10 / 27Find the argument behind an abstract paragraph

Phase 1 of 5about 51 min

Lessonphase 1 of 5 · 5 min

Find the argument behind an abstract paragraph

Goal: Summarise a paragraph's topic and controlling claim · Recognise examples, concessions and conclusions as different parts of the argument · Choose headings at the right level of generality

  1. A strong heading names what a paragraph says about its subject. 'Public consultation' supplies only a topic; 'Why equal invitations can still produce unequal participation' supplies the controlling claim. In abstract paragraphs, the central idea may be a relationship such as a trade-off, a hidden assumption or an unintended consequence. Look for that relationship instead of collecting repeated nouns.
  2. Read the opening and closing sentences, then test your summary against the middle. The opening may introduce a position that the writer later qualifies or rejects. Examples should fit beneath your heading as evidence for it. If your heading explains one colourful example but leaves the rest of the paragraph unaccounted for, it is probably too narrow.
  3. Compare plausible headings on scope and stance. 'The failure of measurement' is stronger than a paragraph arguing for several complementary measures. 'A historical account of registration' misreads a paragraph that uses history to explain a current limitation. Write a short provisional heading before comparing the supplied ones, then ask which candidate covers the paragraph with the fewest unsupported additions.

A worked example

BeforeParagraph: 'A council can make grants appear fair by offering identical application forms. Yet applicants differ in the time, language support and records they can draw on. Equal paperwork can therefore conceal unequal practical access.' Learner heading: 'The design of application forms'.

AfterA better heading is 'When identical procedures conceal unequal access'. The paragraph uses application forms to challenge a simple idea of fairness.

Form design is the setting. The controlling claim is the gap between formal equality and practical access, established by 'Yet' and the final sentence.

Use it elsewhere

Take six paragraphs from a new Academic passage and write a heading of no more than eight words for each before seeing the options. After matching, explain why the nearest wrong heading fails. Measure success by both correct matches and accurate reasons for rejecting the closest distractors.