IELTS notebook · Band 7.5 · Learn · Reading

Lesson 12 / 27Infer only what the text supports

Phase 1 of 5about 48 min

Lessonphase 1 of 5 · 5 min

Infer only what the text supports

Goal: Preserve the population, time and strength of a claim when paraphrasing · Distinguish contradiction from an unanswered comparison · Recognise unsupported causes, reversals and generalisations

  1. A sound inference adds no new assumption. If a text says that twelve of twenty workshops retained staff, you can infer that not all did. You cannot infer why the others lost staff unless the passage explains it. At this level, attractive answers often preserve the topic while changing one relationship: an association becomes a cause, a sample becomes a population, or a possibility becomes a certainty.
  2. Compare claims on five dimensions: who, when, how much, compared with what, and with what certainty. 'Lower than last year' does not mean 'the lowest ever'. 'Only sites with storage qualified' makes storage necessary for qualification; it does not establish that every site with storage qualified. Keep the direction of a condition as carefully as you keep its vocabulary.
  3. In TRUE/FALSE/NOT GIVEN, FALSE requires incompatible information, while NOT GIVEN leaves a necessary detail unsettled. The same distinction applies to YES/NO/NOT GIVEN when Academic questions ask about the writer's views. These exercises use the complete extract supplied. Do not supply plausible social, scientific or economic explanations from your own knowledge. Quote the evidence, then identify the exact step the proposed answer adds.

A worked example

BeforeExtract: 'After the reading room extended its hours, attendance rose. A nearby study centre closed during the same month, and the report did not separate the effects.' Learner: TRUE to 'The longer hours caused the entire rise in attendance.'

AfterNOT GIVEN. Attendance rose after the change, but the report 'did not separate the effects'. Neither the entire rise nor no rise is attributed to the longer hours.

Sequence in time establishes what followed what. It does not by itself establish a cause, still less an exclusive cause. A competing change creates uncertainty without proving the proposed cause false.

Use it elsewhere

Take six mistakes from a fresh Reading set. Classify each as scope, comparison, cause, condition or certainty. Rewrite each wrong option into a claim the passage actually supports. Repeat the same question types on a new passage and compare both accuracy and time.