Lesson
Reject plausible distractors in multiple choice
Goal: Match the question's focus before judging its options · Reject true details that do not answer the question · Test every clause of an option against precise evidence
- Read the stem as a request for a particular relationship. 'Why did the team change the method?' asks for a reason, while 'What happened after the change?' asks for an outcome. A distractor may be entirely true and still answer the wrong question. Before reading the options closely, give yourself a short provisional answer in ordinary language, then find the option that preserves it.
- Plausible distractors often combine one supported phrase with one unsupported extension. An option may correctly mention a pilot but wrongly say it proved a permanent benefit. Another may borrow words from the passage while reversing who did what. Test the entire proposition: subject, action, scope and qualification. A half-supported option is not fully supported.
- Reject an option for a named reason: wrong focus, wrong actor, wrong time, excessive strength, reversed cause or missing evidence. Do not reject an option merely because its words differ from the passage. The correct answer often compresses several sentences into a paraphrase. If two options seem viable, identify the single word or relationship on which they differ and return to the relevant evidence.
A worked example
BeforeQuestion: Why did the archive retain handwritten logs? Extract: 'Digital records made searches faster. However, staff kept handwritten logs because power failures could interrupt access. The logs were also familiar to long-serving staff.' Learner chooses 'Staff were reluctant to learn new software.'
AfterThe supported reason is continuity during power failures. 'Because power failures could interrupt access' answers why the logs were retained. Familiarity is mentioned, but reluctance to learn is not.
The distractor attaches an invented motive to a true detail. The correct option must preserve the stated reason, not merely refer to something else in the paragraph.
Use it elsewhere
For six multiple-choice questions in an unseen Academic passage, note the correct evidence and give each rejected option a one-line reason. Time the second set separately. Improve by removing repeated searches, not by deciding from keyword overlap.