IELTS notebook · Band 7.5 · Learn · Reading

Lesson 14 / 27Whose claim is it? Separate the writer from reported views

Phase 1 of 5about 48 min

Lessonphase 1 of 5 · 5 min

Whose claim is it? Separate the writer from reported views

Goal: Track who owns each claim across reporting clauses and pronouns · Distinguish endorsement, reservation and explicit rejection · Answer Academic YES/NO/NOT GIVEN questions without importing a quoted speaker's beliefs

  1. An Academic passage can contain several voices inside one paragraph. A researcher may recommend a policy, a campaigner may criticise it, and the writer may accept only part of either position. Recognising the topic is not enough. Attach every important proposition to its owner, then look for the writer's response. Reporting a belief does not establish that the writer shares it.
  2. Separate the content of a claim from the writer's attitude towards it. Phrases such as 'rightly observes' endorse a point; 'overlooks' challenges it; 'whether this follows remains unclear' withholds judgement. A concession accepts a limited point without accepting the conclusion built on it. Track the precise scope: agreeing that a trial is promising does not mean agreeing that nationwide adoption is justified.
  3. For Academic YES/NO/NOT GIVEN, compare the statement with the writer's view. Choose NO only when a conflicting view is expressed; absence of endorsement is not itself disagreement. A reported opinion alone may leave the writer's position NOT GIVEN. These labels train Academic Reading. In every item below, the supplied extract is the complete evidence available; fictional names identify voices, not outside authorities.

A worked example

BeforeExtract: 'Dr Vale calls the automated catalogue a complete replacement for specialist staff. Its speed is impressive. Nevertheless, a catalogue cannot decide whether a disputed description is ethically acceptable; specialist judgement remains essential.' Learner: YES to 'The writer believes specialist staff can be entirely replaced.'

AfterNO. 'A complete replacement' belongs to Dr Vale. The writer accepts the speed advantage but says 'specialist judgement remains essential', which contradicts complete replacement.

The positive middle sentence endorses one benefit, not Vale's entire proposal. The contrast and final clause establish the writer's own position.

Use it elsewhere

On a fresh Academic passage, label five claims W for writer or with a speaker's initials. Answer the associated questions before checking the key. For each error, record whether you lost the speaker, the qualification or the writer's response; then repeat with a different passage.