Lesson
Task 2: extend an idea through explanation, example and judgement
Goal: Develop a relevant claim by explaining how and why it works · Use specific examples without inventing evidence · Qualify a claim at the point where its mechanism stops working · Connect each paragraph's reasoning to the exact question and position
- An extended idea gives the reader a route from claim to conclusion. 'Subsidised transport helps workers' is only a starting point. Explain which workers, what barrier the subsidy changes and how that change could affect their choices. If a cheaper fare makes a distant vacancy affordable to reach, the connection to employment becomes visible. More sentences help only when they supply a missing step, a relevant example or a useful qualification.
- An example should demonstrate the mechanism, not repeat the claim in different words. A hypothetical worker choosing between two jobs can show why travel cost matters. Present that case as an illustration, using imagine, for example or could where appropriate; do not disguise it as a survey or invent percentages. You can also support an argument through clear reasoning and familiar observations. An unsupported reference to research does not become evidence because it sounds academic.
- A well-developed paragraph remains tied to the task. If the question asks whether one use of public money should take priority, show why its benefits matter relative to the alternative, not simply why it has benefits. Address a limitation when it changes the judgement: lower fares cannot create a bus route where none exists. Qualification should refine the recommendation, and the final implication should follow from the reasoning. No fixed sentence count or paragraph formula guarantees a band.
A worked example
BeforeCouncils should subsidise evening buses because transport is important. This helps everyone and makes society better. For example, buses are useful for workers.
AfterCouncils should consider subsidising evening buses on routes serving large workplaces. When the last bus leaves before a shift ends, a low-paid worker may have to pay for a taxi or turn down the shift, so a later service can make the job financially viable. For example, an extra departure shortly after a factory's closing time could allow several workers to share a scheduled journey home. The subsidy would be harder to justify on a rarely used route, so a trial should measure demand before permanent funding is agreed.
The paragraph identifies the affected workers, explains the timing and cost mechanism, illustrates it with a hypothetical departure and limits the recommendation by demand. It replaces 'helps everyone' with a specific, testable rationale without inventing a study or claiming the trial has already succeeded.
Use it elsewhere
Take the shortest body paragraph in your last Task 2 response. Label claim, mechanism, illustration and implication where they actually appear. Add only the missing reasoning, then remove any repeated claim. The constructed tasks are paragraph practice, not complete essays or automatic band scores.