An original learner script written for practice, marked the way an examiner-trainer would comment on it. The bands are our judgement, not an official IELTS result.
8.5 Annotated copies · Writing
Writing Task 2 · band 8.5
IELTS · Writing Task 2
The task
Cities should accommodate growing populations mainly by increasing housing density in existing neighbourhoods rather than by building on undeveloped land.
To what extent do you agree or disagree? Give reasons and relevant examples. Write at least 250 words.
Marked copy · Band 8.5
Select a highlighted passage to see the examiner-trainer's note.
As cities grow, building more homes in existing neighbourhoods should normally take priority over spreading into undeveloped areas. I agree with that approach, provided density is planned around the capacity of local services1 rather than treated as a target to be maximised everywhere.
The strongest reason is that established districts already contain much of what makes housing useful. A flat within reach of jobs, shops and a railway station offers more than accommodation2: it can reduce the time and expense involved in ordinary activities. More residents will inevitably support more frequent public transport3. Where homes can be added without displacing existing residents4, the city can make fuller use of infrastructure that has already required substantial investment.
Outward expansion also consumes land that may be difficult to recover. Once roads and houses divide an undeveloped area, later attempts to create continuous open space become expensive and complicated. Building within the existing urban boundary can be a solution of considerable effectiveness5 in preserving that possibility. This does not mean every empty plot should remain untouched, but it gives cities a reason to examine the capacity of land they already occupy before extending further.
Density nevertheless has costs when the supporting services are neglected. Adding apartments to a district whose schools and drainage system are already stretched merely concentrates unmet needs6. Permission for substantial development should therefore be linked to a credible plan for increasing capacity, with public space considered alongside the number of homes. The relevant comparison is between properly serviced neighbourhoods, not between a crowded district and an idealised new suburb7.
Some peripheral development will still be appropriate where existing areas cannot absorb growth at a reasonable cost8. My preference is therefore for density as a planning presumption, not an absolute prohibition on expansion9. Cities should first establish what their existing neighbourhoods can accommodate, then justify additional land use against the realistic alternatives.
1
2
3→ A larger local population can strengthen demand for more frequent public transport, provided operators can expand the service.
4
5→ an effective way
6
7
8→ where strengthening already constrained infrastructure would cost far more than a compact extension beside an existing railway station
9
By criterion
Task Response
8.0
The position is clear and qualified throughout. Access, infrastructure, land consumption and service capacity are developed as mechanisms rather than a list. The inevitable transport-frequency claim overreaches, and the final peripheral-development exception would benefit from a concrete explanation of when it applies.
Coherence and Cohesion
9.0
Each paragraph adds a distinct part of the judgement and the concessions refine the original position. Reference is precise; the closing presumption follows naturally from the comparison of serviced alternatives.
Lexical Resource
8.0
The vocabulary is broad and mostly exact: 'displacing existing residents', 'concentrates unmet needs' and 'planning presumption'. The phrase 'a solution of considerable effectiveness' is inflated and less natural than a direct verb.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
9.0
Conditional, concessive, relative and comparative structures are consistently accurate. Complex sentences retain clear subjects and clause relationships; punctuation and agreement are controlled throughout.
Overall8.5Atelier · IELTS
Three changes for the next band
Illustrative teacher estimate: 8.5 for this 312-word response. Organisation and grammatical control are very strong. One overconfident causal link, a lightly developed exception and an inflated phrase leave room for improvement in task response and lexical precision.
Replace the automatic link between population and service frequency with an explicit condition about capacity or funding.
Develop the peripheral-development exception with one concrete comparison that shows when the preferred policy should yield.
Replace inflated noun phrases with direct verbs or predicates, keeping qualifications that change the meaning.