IELTS notebook · Band 8.5 · Learn · Reading

Lesson 14 / 27Subtle NOT GIVEN: locate the missing relationship

Phase 1 of 5about 53 min

Lessonphase 1 of 5 · 5 min

Subtle NOT GIVEN: locate the missing relationship

Goal: Distinguish contradiction from an unstated comparison, cause or intention · Preserve quantifiers, time frames and attribution when testing a statement · Justify NOT GIVEN by identifying the exact information that is missing

  1. Near the top of the Reading scale, the difficult decision is often between a plausible conclusion and a conclusion the passage actually establishes. A paragraph may mention both objects in a comparison without comparing them. It may give an outcome without its cause, or describe a policy without its author's intention. Break the statement into actor, action, scope and relationship. Matching three parts does not establish the fourth.
  2. Use a three-way evidence test. TRUE requires support for the whole factual statement; FALSE requires incompatible information about the same subject, measure and period. NOT GIVEN applies when neither is established. A narrower statement is not automatically a contradiction of a broader one: 'some benefited' does not tell you whether all benefited. By contrast, 'some did not benefit' contradicts 'all benefited'. For Academic questions about the writer's views, apply the same distinction using YES, NO and NOT GIVEN, while keeping quoted opinions separate from the writer's position.
  3. Do not try to prove an absence by rereading indefinitely. Find the relevant discussion, inspect its surrounding sentences and identify the missing link. Could two situations, one making the statement true and one making it false, both fit the text? That is a useful audit for an unresolved claim, provided you have searched the relevant passage. The exercises use short, self-contained extracts; in a full test, the required evidence may be elsewhere in the passage.

A worked example

BeforeText: 'The archive digitised its fragile maps first. No record was kept of which maps readers requested most often.' Statement: 'The maps digitised first were the most frequently requested.' Incorrect answer: FALSE, because fragility was the priority.

AfterNOT GIVEN. 'Digitised its fragile maps first' identifies the selection criterion. 'No record was kept' leaves the relationship between fragility and demand unknown; the fragile maps might or might not have been the most requested.

A reason for selection is not an exclusion of every other characteristic. FALSE would require evidence that at least one other group was requested more often, or that the selected maps were not the most requested.

Use it elsewhere

Use an unseen Academic passage. For every uncertain TRUE/FALSE/NOT GIVEN or YES/NO/NOT GIVEN answer, write a short evidence note after timing ends. Count separately missing comparisons, unsupported causes and mistaken contradictions; repair the most frequent category before another timed attempt.