Lesson
Task 2 at the top end: a precise position, fully supported
Goal: Answer the prompt's exact scope and degree of agreement · Develop claims through mechanisms, examples and implications · Use a substantive concession to refine rather than obscure a position · Produce a complete essay whose conclusion follows from its argument
- An upper-band Task 2 argument answers the precise question, including its restrictions. In the prompt used here, the issue is not whether work experience can be useful. It is whether every undergraduate should have to complete a workplace placement before graduating. A response that praises practical skills without judging that universal requirement remains incomplete. Decide your degree of agreement and the principle behind it. A qualified position can be decisive: support a learning objective while rejecting one compulsory route where quality or access cannot be secured. Explain that distinction instead of merely saying that both sides have advantages.
- Development means making the reasoning available to the reader. A claim that placements improve learning needs a mechanism: students apply knowledge under real constraints, receive feedback and revise their decisions. An example should show that mechanism at work rather than repeat the claim with a student's name attached. The implication then connects the example back to the disputed requirement. You do not need invented research, percentages or famous authorities. A clearly hypothetical example can support a plausible argument when its logic is explained. Avoid making a universal conclusion from an example that establishes only a possible benefit.
- A sophisticated position deals with the strongest relevant objection. If placements are optional, students with more contacts may secure more opportunities; that is a serious concern. You can answer it through university support and common learning standards without assuming that every available workplace offers equivalent educational value. Let the objection influence your recommendation. Keep each paragraph responsible for a distinct part of the reasoning and make the conclusion resolve the prompt at the same scope as the introduction. Complete Task 2 responses require at least 250 words; the final exercise uses a 40-minute practice allocation, including planning and checking.
A worked example
BeforePrompt: Universities should require every undergraduate to complete a workplace placement before graduating. To what extent do you agree or disagree? Draft position: 'Work experience is useful because it prepares students for work. There are advantages and disadvantages, so universities should consider the issue carefully.'
AfterI support making practical learning available to all undergraduates, but not making a workplace placement an unconditional requirement for graduation. Where a suitable placement cannot be secured, an assessed project can test relevant capabilities without making students' progress depend on access to a particular employer.
'Every undergraduate' and 'before graduating' create a universal compulsory rule. The revision directly rejects that unconditional rule, explains the access problem and proposes an alternative linked to the educational objective. It does not evade the question by merely praising work experience.
Use it elsewhere
Choose an unfamiliar opinion question containing all, only, compulsory or before. Plan a position in four minutes, then test whether each body paragraph addresses the restricted proposal rather than only the general topic.