Warm-up
Before reading · whose account is this?
Read the writer’s role before deciding what the document can establish. A direct observation, a record, a prediction and an interpretation have different evidential force. Compare the two sources for agreement and limitation; do not manufacture a compromise by averaging incompatible claims.
Exercise 1 · choose
Before comparing the accounts, which question best helps you judge a claim?
Sure?
Exercise 2 · choose
A log says a key was left at reception. What further evidence would establish that a volunteer received the information?
Sure?
Exercise 3 · choose
Two accounts appear to give incompatible timings. How should a careful reader proceed?
Sure?