Warm-up
The commission · who needs to act?
Source A — room offers. Orchard Commons Studio is a fictional adult creative-learning group in Northern Ireland. Its coordinator has two written offers. The mill room costs sixty pounds per session and includes overnight storage, but it is upstairs.
The library room costs eighty pounds per session and is at ground level, but large materials must be removed after each session. The mill offers six evening dates. The library offers four afternoons. These are fictional offers for this source pack, not information about real venues or current prices.
Source B — preference survey. Thirty people answered the studio's questionnaire. Eighteen preferred the library room, seven preferred the mill and five selected no preference. The question described the rooms but did not ask whether respondents could attend an afternoon session.
Eighteen out of thirty is sixty per cent of the responding sample. The remaining forty per cent should not be described as opposition to the library, because five people explicitly selected no preference. The studio has not established that all prospective participants responded.
Source C — travel and volunteer notes. Four respondents said that the last return bus relevant to their journey would leave before the proposed evening session ended. The notes do not establish whether those four are also among the eighteen library supporters.
Two volunteers said they could help carry equipment upstairs at the mill. Their offer is useful for handling materials, but it does not establish that every participant can use an upstairs room. Travel, material carrying and individual access are related practical issues, not interchangeable measures.
Nora proposes a small trial rather than an immediate six-session commitment. Malik initially suggests an earlier library session, then checks the offer and realises that the available dates are afternoons, not evenings that can simply be moved.
This correction changes the question the studio must ask. A room may be preferred in the survey yet unsuitable at the offered time for some respondents. The group needs to test the new time explicitly rather than assume that preference for a room includes availability at every time.
A draft recommendation describes the library as the obvious choice because it is more popular and accessible. Nora removes obvious and makes the scope explicit. Ground-level location is a relevant feature, but the group has not checked all individual access requirements.
The library also creates a trade-off: volunteers must carry large materials away, or the programme must use a smaller set. Spending more per session may be worthwhile for a particular trial, but the figures alone do not identify a universal best option.
Decision note. On balance, the proposed recommendation is to confirm one offered library afternoon, ask participants about attendance at that time and explain a reduced materials set. If those conditions cannot be met, the studio should reopen the comparison.
A responsible source pack should attribute each factual claim to the relevant fictional source, preserve the survey's no-preference category, and show how the travel and volunteer notes affect the plan. A shared recommendation may include recorded reservations; it does not require inventing unanimous agreement.
Exercise 1 · choose
Which recommendation fits the available evidence?
Exercise 2 · choose
What must the committee be able to do after reading the recommendation?
Exercise 3 · write
Before studying the model, write 60–100 words stating your provisional recommendation, one supporting fact and one condition.
0 wordsmin 60 · max 100
Check your text