Warm-up
Your fictional briefing card
Source A — expressions of interest and conditions
The Celyn Learning Room collected twenty-six expressions of interest in an additional evening group. Fourteen people selected Tuesday as their preferred evening and twelve selected Thursday. Each person could select one preference only, so the two figures account for all twenty-six responses.
The form did not ask whether respondents could attend their less-preferred evening. These figures therefore describe first preferences, not confirmed bookings or an exhaustive division into people who can attend only one night.
The organisers have agreed two prerequisites for opening the additional group in this fictional case: a suitable room must be confirmed and two tutors must be available. Neither a high number of requests nor a provisional room offer satisfies both conditions.
At the time of the record, the room remains provisional and one tutor has confirmed. A second tutor has offered to check availability but has not agreed to teach. The record contains no basis for treating that offer as completed staffing.
Should both conditions be met, the organisers can allocate places through a separate booking process. Confirmed capacity would then be twenty-four places across the existing and additional groups. Requests beyond that capacity could remain on a waiting list, but inclusion on the list would not guarantee a later place.
The recorder recommends that the first invitation explain the distinction between an expression of interest and an allocation. This is an administrative recommendation, not evidence that either outstanding prerequisite will definitely be met.
Source B — a learner representative’s response
I welcome the proposal, but I am concerned about how a conditional offer will be heard. When the earlier notice said that another evening was being arranged, some people understood it as a confirmed place.
I cannot say how widespread that interpretation was. Three people contacted me, and their questions may reflect a difficulty that others share or a misunderstanding limited to those conversations. Either way, the next message needs to distinguish an intention from a commitment.
I recommend that the existing group should remain available while the additional one is considered. Some participants have already arranged their travel around it. Were that group to move without a confirmed alternative, those arrangements could be disrupted.
This is a hypothetical consequence, not a prediction that the organisers intend to close the group. I would like the invitation to state what stays the same as clearly as it states what might change. The current plan has room for both pieces of information.
Please also ask whether people could attend their second-choice evening. A preference is useful, but it may not reveal the condition that actually determines attendance. Should the need arise, a waiting list could preserve contact with people who cannot be offered a place immediately.
It should not be presented as a promise of a future session. My proposal is for clear information and a route to ask questions, not for lowering the agreed conditions or assuming that the demand figures are meaningless.
Source C — coordinator’s decision note
The coordinator proposes a conditional decision rather than an immediate launch. The extra group should go ahead only after room access and both tutors are confirmed. Until that point, staff may collect preferences and explain the proposal, but they should not allocate places.
This restriction is intended to prevent a provisional arrangement from being communicated as a settled commitment. It does not require staff to remain silent about a useful possibility.
The note provides two contingencies. Should requests exceed the confirmed capacity, staff can maintain a waiting list and explain how updates will be sent. Were the room to become unavailable before invitations were issued, the existing group would continue and the additional proposal would be paused.
No alternative venue has been confirmed. The coordinator therefore rejects a draft sentence promising that the class will run somewhere else in any circumstances. A fallback needs a real arrangement behind it, not merely reassuring wording.
Looking back at the earlier notice, the coordinator writes: “Had we checked the room status before announcing the plan, we would have avoided an unnecessary correction.” This counterfactual acknowledges a past communication error.
It does not establish that the room is now free, nor does it imply that every enquiry resulted from that error. For the revised process, the coordinator recommends that one named volunteer should verify both prerequisites before invitations are released.
A second person will check that the message preserves the conditions. The next review is therefore a check on readiness, not a judgement that every possible future difficulty has disappeared.
Exercise 1 · transform
Retrieve the past counterfactual: remove if and begin Had.
If we had checked the room, we would have corrected the notice.
Exercise 2 · choose
You have twenty seconds to introduce the original proposal. Which opening keeps the decision usable?
Exercise 3 · choose
During rehearsal, a listener says, I missed whether the second tutor agreed. What should your next turn do?