Warm-up
A room, two clocks and a first impression
At the fictional Gleann House archive, Erin sees a room before she knows why it has been rearranged. Read the short account, then the earlier gardening-group example.
A room read too quickly
Erin arrived at the fictional Gleann House archive in Northern Ireland at 18.20 by her phone. The wall clock showed 18.05. Before her stood an empty display table. Beside the window lay a crate covered with a blue cloth.
In the distance, a trolley rattled. The room gave her a sense of unease: the volunteers seemed to have left before she arrived. That was her interpretation, not something she had witnessed.
The caretaker’s log later showed that the display had been moved at 18.10 to make space for a talk at 19.00. The wall clock was fifteen minutes slow. “The volunteers seem to have prepared the room” is now a better inference than “They seem to have cancelled the talk”.
The opening’s unusual word order guides attention towards the setting. A practical report can simply say, “An empty table stood before her.” It does not need to imitate the narrative style.
Retrieval bridge — a gardening group
A fictional gardening group received ten replies from thirty members. Four respondents asked for later meetings; the remaining six gave other preferences. Only then did the coordinator compare the replies with the current timetable. Under no circumstances should ten replies be described as everyone’s view.
Later meetings, she was willing to test; a permanent change, she was not. In particular, two respondents needed daylight for travel. What is at stake is access to the trial, not proof of a unanimous preference.
Exercises 1–5
5 questionsTea break · Word of the day
viewpoint
A scene can stay with one observer. A later explanation can change that observer’s interpretation without erasing the first impression.
Exercise 2 · choose
The gardening group received ten replies from thirty members. Which contrast must its summary retain?
Sure?Exercise 3 · put in order
Begin with Only after checking the replies and build the past-tense statement.
Tap the words to place them hereExercise 4 · choose
The group says, “What is at stake is access to the trial.” What does the phrase identify?
Sure?Exercise 5 · choose
Erin sees an empty table and concludes that the volunteers have left. Which part is directly observed?
Sure?