Warm-up
A stronger claim needs stronger grounds
Retrieval bridge — a quiet music room
Before the door stood an empty music stand. In the distance, someone was wheeling a case along the corridor. Leila felt a sense of unease and thought practice had ended. A note later showed that the scores had been taken for copying at 16.00, before a practice scheduled for 17.00.
The scores seem to have been moved for preparation, not after the event. From that point onwards, Leila separated what she had seen from what she had inferred. Two singers were booked; their actual arrival was not recorded.
A prediction stronger than the record
The fictional Brae Book Room in Scotland is considering four more Saturday book-making sessions. Its previous four Saturdays recorded 20, 22, 18 and 24 attendances. Four earlier weekday sessions recorded 12, 14, 13 and 15. These are event attendances, not counts of different people. Topics varied. The first two Saturdays had extra publicity; the last two had a guest demonstrator.
“Saturdays are bound to double turnout” is stronger than the record supports. The totals are 84 and 54, not a doubling, and the comparison does not isolate the day. Saturday sessions may well attract more visits, but the conclusion remains tentative.
Extra publicity or the guest is a plausible explanation for part of the difference. A colleague says, “We might just fill all thirty places next time, though I would not plan on it.” That last sentence leaves room for a small possibility rather than promising full attendance.
For the separate staffing question, the proposed opening is noon and the current rota ends at eleven. If those times stay fixed, someone else must cover the opening. This timing mismatch gives the staffing claim firmer grounds than a forecast about attendance.
Exercises 1–5
5 questionsExercise 1 · choose
Before the recap, interpret “Before the door stood an empty music stand”.
Sure?Tea break · Word of the day
tentative
A tentative conclusion remains open to revision. It can still guide a practical next step when its assumptions are clear.
Exercise 3 · choose
The note says the scores were taken for copying at 16.00 for practice at 17.00. Which conclusion respects that sequence?
Sure?Exercise 4 · match
Match each expression from the music-room account to its meaning.
tap a card on the left, then its match on the right
Exercise 5 · choose
Two singers were booked, but their arrival was not recorded. What can the reader safely report?
Sure?