Warm-up
Before the review · preserve the actual disagreement
In this original fictional case, the depot log records two vehicle movements through the east gate between 20:00 and 21:00 on Tuesday the 12th. A residents’ diary records five movements through that gate in the same hour.
Both documents define a movement as one entry or one exit, so one vehicle arriving and leaving counts twice. They are not counting different kinds of event. Their counts remain incompatible unless further evidence explains the discrepancy.
Neither averaging the counts nor selecting the more official-looking document resolves it.
The depot coordinator proposes retaining the timetable on the grounds that the log records only two movements. The residents object because their diary records five, and because a revised notice arrived after they had organised a rota.
The chair can acknowledge both purposes without endorsing either count. To corroborate a claim is to add relevant supporting evidence, not simply to repeat it. An independent gate record might help, but none has yet been checked.
“Perfect timing” after a late notice might be ironic, sincere about another event, or deliberately ambiguous; wording, surrounding turns and heard delivery must be considered together.
Retrieval card · a separate community-kitchen call
A community kitchen is discussing a new collection point. In an informal call, Ali says, “The side entrance, it is easier to find.” Jo replies, “The thing is, the sign is hidden when the door is open.”
A formal summary should preserve the information without mechanically carrying over every spoken head or tail. The participants are comparing access routes, not deciding who is allowed to speak.
Ali asks, “We have checked the side entrance, haven’t we?” Jo says no: only the front route has been tested. The tag is therefore a check that receives a correction, not proof of agreement.
After an interruption, Ali resumes with “As I was saying”; Jo uses “To put it another way” to restate the sign problem. “Wouldn’t you agree?” could seek alignment, but the chair must allow a genuine refusal rather than interpret silence as consent.
Leah’s proposed checking plan · meeting extract
Then the first action is to preserve all three records and check their windows, units and coverage. After that, we compare the individual events. Separately, I propose one dated notice before a rota is requested. That would repair the communication problem without asking either side to withdraw an untested claim.
Exercises 1–5
5 questionsExercise 1 · choose
In the community-kitchen card, Ali asks whether the side entrance has been checked. What does Jo’s no establish?
Sure?Exercise 2 · choose
Ali says, “The side entrance, it is easier to find.” Which version fits a neutral written summary while preserving his comparison?
Sure?Exercise 3 · fill in
Use the four-word expression from the retrieval card that resumes an interrupted point.
Ali: , the side entrance still needs a trial.
Sure?Exercise 4 · choose
Jo says, “The thing is, the sign is hidden when the door is open.” What does the opening phrase do?
Sure?Tea break · Word of the day
discrepancy
noun
A discrepancy is a difference that needs explanation. Naming it clearly is useful: it does not accuse either writer of dishonesty, and it does not disappear because a compromise sounds polite.
- a discrepancy between records
- account for a discrepancy