Warm-up
Three sources, three different jobs
This source pack concerns the fictional Rowan Community Rooms pilot. Source A is the internal procedure. Source B records a small community panel’s difficulties with an earlier notice. Source C contains the communications editor’s draft and revision note.
First identify what each source can establish. Then read across the texts by question: what may a group request, what must it wait for, where can it get help, and which claims need checking? Use only the fictional case; do not treat it as a real service announcement.
Separate vocabulary case: the key-collection dispute
A fictional hall office records two key collections between 16:00 and 17:00 on Monday, while a volunteer sheet records four collections in that same hour at the same desk. Both count each collection event once.
The accounts therefore conflict; one source’s tidy layout does not corroborate its total. A separate access file covers only the first fifteen minutes. The organiser favours a change on the grounds that late notices made the process confusing, but confusion does not prove either count.
In a discussion, a volunteer says “Excellent, another notice after we have left” and then explains that this is a complaint about timing, not praise. A chair checks the intended stance rather than treating the positive word as proof of approval.
The volunteer agrees to compare the records while retaining the four-collection claim. The partial access file cannot establish the whole hour’s total. With transcript support, this can be analysed as context; realised prosody remains unobserved without a reviewed recording.
Exercise 1 · choose
Which source should you check first to establish the pilot’s rules?
Exercise 2 · choose
What is the most useful question when comparing these texts?
Exercise 3 · choose
A panel member dislikes a technical phrase. What can that comment establish on its own?