Warm-up
Before we start · the claim and its boundary
The fictional Cwm Archive has tested a simplified booking page with eight volunteers. Six completed a booking unaided, two requested help and no timed comparison was made.
A draft proposal says the new page is faster for all visitors and will remove the need for staff assistance. A reviewer asks the writer to substantiate those claims rather than merely change the tone.
The reviewer is asking for a change to what the text claims. Identify the problem before repairing the sentence: a correct verb form, a polite tone and a supported proposition are different achievements. Keep the useful finding while changing the unsupported inference.
Exercises 1–5
5 questionsExercise 1 · choose
Which revision addresses the missing speed evidence?
Sure?Exercise 2 · choose
Which form completes the reviewer’s sentence: “The two requests ___ still relevant”?
Sure?Exercise 3 · choose
A draft is grammatically correct but says all eight volunteers booked without help. What needs repair first?
Sure?Exercise 4 · match
Match each wording problem to the most precise diagnosis.
tap a card on the left, then its match on the right
Tea break · Word of the day
back to the drawing board
phrase
This phrase suggests reconsidering a design or plan. A review does not always require starting again: retain the parts supported by evidence and change the proposition that fails.
- revise a claim
- retain a useful feature
- a substantive change