Warm-up
The meaning before the rule
The fictional Willow Footbridge trial has three sources: Ben’s weekday-morning log, the coordinator’s note and Sal’s account of a residents’ discussion. They do not measure the same thing.
You will compare reporting verbs, tense and negation. Your task is to preserve what each source says, how strongly it says it and what it leaves unresolved. A source’s name cannot make an invented proposition accurate.
Case evidence: Ben’s log covers ten weekday mornings. Seven openings matched the posted time and three were late. It contains no evening or weekend observations and no measure of popularity. The coordinator writes, The trial may help us identify where communication needs to improve. A decision about the next arrangement will follow the review. In Sal’s discussion, several participants found the notices hard to follow and one said a changed notice had helped.
Sal did not ask every bridge user or conduct a representative survey.
For the opening recap, an archive contributor says I didn’t take nothing from the table. In the usage stipulated here, two negative forms express one negative proposition: the contributor took no objects on that occasion. This pattern is called negative concord.
A dialect is a systematic language variety. A standard convention is the formal norm chosen for a particular publication. Stigmatisation means negative social judgement of a speaker or variety. The archive keeps the source quotation unchanged and labels any visitor paraphrase.
Exercises 1–5
5 questionsTea break · Did you know…
A shorter report can remain faithful if it keeps four things visible: whose claim it is, what it says, how strongly it is supported and where its scope ends.
Exercise 2 · choose
In the archive example, which visitor caption preserves the stipulated meaning and its one-occasion scope?
Sure?Exercise 3 · match
Match each description to the term introduced above.
tap a card on the left, then its match on the right
Exercise 4 · choose
An editor silently changes the archive quotation to the formal caption wording. What has gone wrong?
Sure?Exercise 5 · choose
Which editorial note explains the formal caption without stigmatising the contributor?
Sure?