Warm-up
A position you can defend and revise
Fictional role card: you mediate a new panel for Alderhaven’s invented North Bridge. The Heritage Circle wants a recognisable act of gratitude; the Families Forum wants work and access limits visible. Use only the fictional source facts given below. Offer accurate panel wording and a transparent next decision about design. In this rehearsal you are the proposal editor, not yourself.
Source facts for this rehearsal: The committee minute of 12 May 1932 records the donor’s undertaking to underwrite the ironwork and a plan for free pedestrian passage from dawn to dusk, with cart charges retained during the initial period.
It does not report every later crossing. A family account recorded in 1994 recalls relatives helping with opening preparations; the narrator does not know all the workers or which jobs were paid. The separate works list mentioned in the minute is not supplied.
The Heritage Circle accepts the corrected access description and wants donor gratitude prominent. The Families Forum accepts the recorded ironwork commitment and wants work equally prominent. The groups have not agreed the layout.
Opening objection: A colleague says, “A panel should honour a gift, not drown it in qualifications.” The proposed phrase “the gift that gave everyone free passage” would erase the pedestrian and time limits.
Exercise 1 · choose
How should you begin answering the colleague’s objection quoted above?
Exercise 2 · choose
A colleague says that gratitude matters. Which reply acknowledges that concern while keeping room for qualification?
Exercise 3 · choose
Which question invites a genuine clarification of the colleague’s objection?