Warm-up
The decision behind the language
Original fictional case: the Lantern Exchange is reviewing six evenings of later opening. An observation note reports 126 entries; an invitation repeats that figure and offers a warm welcome; a visitor describes making progress with a form while leaving one page unfinished.
Rae chairs the discussion, Kit is the analyst and Jo contributes the situated experience. The task is to retain what each source contributes without claiming that access is now universal.
How the count was made: The Lantern Exchange counted 126 entries during six trial evenings. The counter recorded passages through the entrance, not distinct visitors, and the staff did not ask people to identify themselves.
Someone who went outside and returned could therefore appear twice. Two entries made during a staff test were removed before the figure was circulated. A short interruption on the fourth evening was noted in the log, but no missing total was invented to fill it.
The count is usable as a description of recorded activity, provided that these qualifications travel with it.
Other evidence: Eighteen attenders voluntarily returned comment cards; people unable to attend are not represented. Jo says the later hours helped her finish most of a form, but she left the final page unfinished.
The invitation borrows the observation note’s figure and begins “A place for everyone, at last.” Its editor says she intended to recognise people previously excluded by working hours, and accepts that the headline does not guarantee universal access.
The phrase may still sound critical of earlier arrangements to some readers; it does not by itself establish an intention to blame staff.
Exercises 1–5
5 questionsTea break · Word of the day
scope of inference
The precision of a number does not decide how broadly it can be used. Entries can describe recorded activity without identifying distinct people, and a real personal benefit can matter without estimating everybody’s experience.
Exercise 2 · choose
Which statement preserves the opening evidence?
Sure?Exercise 3 · match
Match each measurement or evidence term to its distinct meaning.
tap a card on the left, then its match on the right
Exercise 4 · choose
After a noisy rehearsal, a librarian says, “You have certainly found a new use for the reading room.” Which question checks the practical implication without claiming to know the librarian’s intention?
Sure?Exercise 5 · choose
Which change narrows a claim more precisely than adding “perhaps” to “everyone benefited”?
Sure?