Reading

Combining sources that agree: synthesise agreement without adding claims

Combining sources that agree shows how two texts can support one shared point while keeping their different details, with examples and questions.

In short

Write the shared point at the level both sources support using both sources, then attach each extra detail to its source. Agreement about one recommendation does not mean the sources agree about every reason or method.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out

Read, then answer the questions

One contact, two proposals

Source A: Visitors to the evening workshop often ask the same question at several desks. A named contact person should receive enquiries before each session and pass them to the relevant organiser. The contact name should appear in the booking email. This would give visitors a clear starting point without expecting one person to solve every problem.

Source B: Volunteers need to know who is handling an unresolved request. Each evening session should have a named contact, recorded on the internal rota. That person should maintain a short handover note so that a colleague can continue the enquiry if the contact leaves early. The proposal concerns continuity1, rather than a change to who approves room bookings.

A careful synthesis begins with their convergence2: both sources recommend a named contact for each session. It then preserves the distinct priorities. Source A focuses on making the contact visible to visitors, whereas Source B emphasises an internal record and handover. Neither source says that the contact must be a manager, and neither promises that all enquiries will be resolved immediately.

This produces a useful summary: Both sources favour a named session contact, with A stressing clear information for visitors and B recommending a rota entry and handover note for volunteers. The sentence keeps the shared proposal and attributes3 the details. Saying that both sources demand a manager-led help desk would change their proposal. Saying only that both discuss communication would be accurate but too broad to explain their common ground4.

Which claims can the summary safely make?

Question 1No account needed
What recommendation do both sources share?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

A named contact for each session. Both texts explicitly recommend a named contact, but neither makes the other two promises.

Question 2No account needed
Which detail belongs specifically to Source A?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

A contact name in the booking email. Source A puts the contact name in an email so visitors know where to begin.

Question 3No account needed
Which summary adds an unsupported claim?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

Both require the contact to be a manager.. Neither text identifies the role as a manager; that detail would be added by the writer.

Question 4No account needed
Why is "both discuss communication" weak?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

It is too broad to state the shared recommendation.. It names a broad topic but misses the specific proposal to have a named contact.

Built from