阅读

整合观点一致的来源:综合共识而不添加主张

整合观点一致的来源:通过例子和问题,学习如何让两篇文本支持同一个共同观点,同时保留各自不同的细节。

要点

用 both sources 按两个来源都能支持的程度写出共同观点,再把每个额外细节归到各自的来源。在某一项建议上一致,并不代表两个来源在每个理由或方法上都一致。

黄色 核心要点蓝色 重点英语表达红色 注意陷阱

先阅读,再回答问题

One contact, two proposals

Source A: Visitors to the evening workshop often ask the same question at several desks. A named contact person should receive enquiries before each session and pass them to the relevant organiser. The contact name should appear in the booking email. This would give visitors a clear starting point without expecting one person to solve every problem.

Source B: Volunteers need to know who is handling an unresolved request. Each evening session should have a named contact, recorded on the internal rota. That person should maintain a short handover note so that a colleague can continue the enquiry if the contact leaves early. The proposal concerns continuity1, rather than a change to who approves room bookings.

A careful synthesis begins with their convergence2: both sources recommend a named contact for each session. It then preserves the distinct priorities. Source A focuses on making the contact visible to visitors, whereas Source B emphasises an internal record and handover. Neither source says that the contact must be a manager, and neither promises that all enquiries will be resolved immediately.

This produces a useful summary: Both sources favour a named session contact, with A stressing clear information for visitors and B recommending a rota entry and handover note for volunteers. The sentence keeps the shared proposal and attributes3 the details. Saying that both sources demand a manager-led help desk would change their proposal. Saying only that both discuss communication would be accurate but too broad to explain their common ground4.

摘要可以稳妥地提出哪些主张?

第 1 题无需账户
两个来源共同提出了什么建议?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

A named contact for each session. 两篇文本都明确建议设立指定联系人,但都没有作出另外两项承诺。

第 2 题无需账户
哪个细节专属于来源 A?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

A contact name in the booking email. 来源 A 把联系人姓名写进邮件,让来访者知道该从哪里开始。

第 3 题无需账户
哪个摘要添加了没有依据的主张?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

Both require the contact to be a manager.. 两篇文本都没有说这个角色必须是经理;这个细节是写作者自己添加的。

第 4 题无需账户
为什么 "both discuss communication" 这个说法不够好?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

It is too broad to state the shared recommendation.. 它只点出了一个宽泛的话题,却漏掉了设立指定联系人这一具体提议。

编写依据