考试练习

Cambridge C2 Proficiency 议论文:范文与构思

借助两篇短文、一篇 255 词的范文、写作计划和检查清单,练习写 Cambridge C2 Proficiency 议论文,概括和评析原文,并加入自己的想法。

要点

在 C2 Proficiency 写作第一部分中,要写240–280 词,概括并评析两篇文章,同时加入自己的想法。Summarise 是简要说明要点;evaluate 是判断论述有多大说服力,并解释原因。只写两段各自独立的概括,还没有完成主要的思考工作。

黄色 核心要点蓝色 重点英语表达红色 注意陷阱

在社区学习室里,其他人准备交谈时,一位成年学习者到了。
议论文可以 summarise and evaluate both views,概括并评析房间里体现的两种观点。 插画:Atelier

C2 第一部分议论文需要做到什么?

同一篇论证中的三项任务
任务读者应该看到什么有用的问题
概括用自己的话表达两篇文章的要点每位作者主张什么?理由是什么?
评析你对理由或假设的判断在什么情况下,这个论证有说服力?有什么局限?
展开你自己有理据支持的立场把两种观点放在一起考虑,可以得出什么?

下面第一篇文章提出两个相互联系的观点:安静的空间能消除实际障碍,时间固定的活动能支持规律学习。第二篇认为,交谈能建立信心,而总出席人数可能无法体现小组的价值。把这些想法带入议论文,再加以审视。可以围绕共同问题组织段落,例如学习机会和证据。

文章 1 怎样看待安静学习?

Adults returning to education often need somewhere quiet to work. At home, caring duties, crowded rooms or unreliable internet access can make sustained study difficult. A community centre that reserves an evening room for independent learning can therefore remove a practical barrier. Regular attendance matters more than a busy opening night: people who return each week may be building a useful habit. Where funds are limited, a predictable study session is a sensible priority. Centres should give learners a place where they can concentrate, with a clear timetable that allows them to plan their work around other responsibilities.

文章 2 怎样看待交谈?

Quiet is valuable, but learning is also a social activity. Informal conversation groups allow adults to test ideas, practise English and ask questions they might hesitate to raise in a classroom. A learner who feels welcome may gain the confidence to join a course later. Replacing these groups with silent study could exclude people who most need encouragement. Numbers alone offer a poor guide to the value of a session: a small group may provide essential support. Community centres should protect a regular time for conversation, even when a different use of the room appears more efficient on paper.

你能结合两篇文章写议论文吗?

Cambridge C2 Proficiency——写作第一部分练习不是官方试卷

阅读上面两篇关于社区中心晚间学习的文章。写一篇议论文,概括并评析两篇文章的要点。尽量使用自己的措辞,并加入自己的想法。写 240–280 词。

(至少 240 个词)

你的答案

你写的内容不会保存或发送。离开前请自行复制。

阅读示范答案

How should a community centre use its limited evening space? The first text favours quiet study, arguing that a reliable room can overcome domestic obstacles and sustain learning habits. The second prioritises conversation, presenting social contact as a route into education. Both are concerned with access, but they identify different barriers.

The case for quiet provision is persuasive because willingness to study is of little use without workable conditions. A dependable evening slot may help adults organise learning around caring duties. Repeat attendance also suggests that the provision meets a continuing need. However, returning regularly is evidence of use rather than proof of educational progress. A centre should ask learners what the room enables them to achieve.

The second text rightly broadens the discussion beyond individual concentration. Conversation can help hesitant learners develop the confidence to participate elsewhere; its value may therefore exceed what attendance figures reveal. Nevertheless, a welcoming atmosphere should not simply be assumed to benefit everyone. Some adults need solitude, and others may find an established group difficult to enter. Both forms of provision deserve scrutiny.

In my view, allocating space should involve those who use it and those who currently stay away. A short trial of different arrangements, followed by feedback from both groups, would reveal more than a competition between headline numbers. Alternating evenings is one option, provided that the timetable remains predictable enough for regular participation. The aim should be to preserve meaningful access to both kinds of learning, rather than treating either silence or conversation as universally preferable.

检查你的草稿

完成之前

这是自我检查工具,不是考试成绩。勾选不会保存。

怎样评析一个观点,而不只是复述?

A summary转述作者的观点。

重点: 原文说了什么

The first text argues that repeat visits indicate a useful habit.
这句话告诉读者作者的理由。

An evaluation检验这个理由能支持什么结论。

重点: 这个观点能在多大程度上推动论证

Repeat visits suggest continuing demand, but they tell us little about what learners achieve.
这句话接受了有用的证据,也解释了它的局限。

范文共 255 词。首段通过 access 联系两篇文章。接下来两段各自转述一种观点,解释其价值,再检验一项局限。最后一段提出实际方案。注意 provided that:方案取决于时间安排是否确实方便大家参与。

哪些短语有助于作出准确判断?

所表达的关系合适时,再使用这个短语
短语用途例句
The case for ... is persuasive because ...解释你为什么接受某个理由The case for quiet provision is persuasive because some adults lack a place to study.
However, ... is evidence of ... rather than ...区分观察结果与更强的结论However, regular attendance is evidence of use rather than proof of progress.
... provided that ...说明必要条件Alternating evenings could work, provided that the timetable stays predictable.
  • The first text is right. The second text is wrong.The first text identifies a practical need, but the second raises a valid concern about social access.

    解释你接受论证的哪部分,以及为什么接受。先判断理由,再展开结论。

  • Both texts prove that every learner needs a quiet room.Both texts discuss access to learning, but they favour different uses of the room.

    把每位作者的立场说清楚。第二篇文章主张保留交谈,所以第一个句子改变了它的意思。

第 1 题无需账户
哪个句子最能联系两篇文章?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

Both writers want better access to learning, but they focus on different barriers.. 这句话找出了共同关切和有意义的差别,让议论文有明确的组织思路。

第 2 题无需账户
哪个句子评析了证据,而不只是概括观点?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

Repeat attendance suggests demand, but it does not show how much learning took place.. 这个句子同时解释理由的价值和局限,这就是评析。

第 3 题无需账户
哪个写作计划最符合任务要求?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

Summarise both views, examine their reasons, then support a practical judgement.. 任务要求在一篇连贯的议论文中结合两篇原文、评析和自己的想法。

第 4 题无需账户
范文最后一段增加了什么?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

A trial and feedback process, with a condition for alternating evenings. 结论针对两种观点提出实际办法,同时保留了建议的条件。

编写依据