考试练习

C2 Proficiency 写作:比较并改进答案

看看优秀的 C2 Proficiency 写作怎样展开:四项评分标准、两篇阅读材料、第 1 部分议论文范文,以及检验论证是否严密的问题。

要点

C2 Proficiency 写作第 1 部分的优秀答案,会把准确概括、清晰评价和自己的观点结合起来。四项评分标准是内容、交际效果、组织结构和语言。仅靠生僻词,不能让答案出色:the figures show use 这样准确说明「数据表明有人使用」的措辞,可能更有助于论证。

黄色 核心要点蓝色 重点英语表达红色 注意陷阱

学习中心内,一张供人安静学习的书桌旁边,有一小群人在交谈。
优秀议论文会评估共用房间背后的两种需要:evaluates both needs。 插图:Atelier

四项写作标准评估什么?

把评分标准变成检查草稿的问题
标准要问的问题检查重点
内容我完整回应了任务吗?准确呈现相关要点,让读者了解所需的全部信息。
交际效果文章实现了写作目的吗?议论文风格合适,能有效呈现复杂观点。
组织结构读者能跟上论证吗?观点安排连贯,段内和段间衔接清楚。
语言我能准确表达自己的意思吗?能灵活、熟练地运用丰富的词汇和语法。

本页把这些标准应用于第 1 部分的议论文。Cambridge 要求根据两篇各约 100 词的文本,写 240—280 词,概括并评价要点,加入自己的想法。阅读每份材料时,既要看主要观点,也要看支撑它的理由。

这两篇文本的要点是什么?

Text 1 - A place to concentrate. For adults who share crowded homes, a quiet public study room can make learning possible. Penmere Learning Hub recently tried using its Tuesday evening room for silent study. Across four evenings, it recorded 36 attendances, including 12 first visits. The coordinator sees this as a reason to make quiet study a regular service: people are already choosing to use it. A calm place, reliable lighting and a desk may matter more than another organised activity. Public learning spaces should respond to these practical needs, especially when learners struggle to find suitable conditions elsewhere.

Text 2 - More than a desk. An informal conversation group also needs an evening space, and Tuesday is its only available slot at Penmere. Replacing the group with quiet study would remove an opportunity for adults to practise speaking and build relationships. The hub cannot pay for another staffed evening this term. Its choice therefore has a cost, even if silent study attracts visitors. Visit totals show that a service is used; they cannot establish that it benefits the community more than the activity it replaces. The hub should examine both needs before giving one group permanent priority.

C2 Proficiency——写作第 1 部分练习不是官方试卷

阅读上方两篇文本,写一篇议论文,概括并评价其中的要点。尽量使用自己的措辞,并加入自己的观点。写 240—280 词。

(至少 240 个词)

你的答案

你写的内容不会保存或发送。离开前请自行复制。

阅读示范答案

The two texts raise a practical question about public learning spaces: how should a limited resource serve adults whose needs differ? The first presents quiet study as a response to poor conditions at home, supported by attendance at a short trial. The second stresses the value of conversation and the cost of removing its only evening session.

The case for silence is persuasive. Access to a desk and adequate lighting can determine whether someone is able to study at all. However, the 36 attendances demonstrate use rather than improved learning, and the 12 first visits do not establish how many additional learners would benefit from a permanent service. The coordinator's proposal therefore moves beyond what the trial alone establishes.

Equally, the conversation group's existing timetable should not settle the issue automatically. Spoken practice and social contact are valuable, but an established activity should still be open to review when other needs emerge. The second text is strongest when it asks the hub to consider what would be lost, rather than treating either activity as an obvious priority.

Since another staffed evening is unaffordable, I would favour a further, limited trial in which the two activities alternate on Tuesdays. This would reduce access to each service, so the hub should consult both groups and record who is unable to attend as well as who comes. A permanent decision could then consider learning needs, continuity and exclusion together. The best use of the room is the one supported by a fair comparison, rather than by the most immediately impressive total.

检查你的草稿

完成之前

这是自我检查工具,不是考试成绩。勾选不会保存。

范文怎样从概括走向评价?

The first text supports quiet study.准确但不完整的概括。

重点: 指出了立场,却省去了理由。

The first presents quiet study as a response to poor conditions at home.
范文写出了建议背后的理由。

The figures demonstrate use rather than improved learning.评价证据究竟支持什么。

重点: 检验数据与建议之间的联系。

The coordinator's proposal therefore moves beyond what the trial alone establishes.
范文说明了推理中的薄弱之处。

留意范文中的四项选择

  • 内容:文章涵盖家庭学习条件、试行情况、对话小组和人员配置的限制。
  • 交际效果:以议论文的语气展开立场,用 I would favour 引出一个有理由支持的建议。
  • 组织结构:Equally 转向第二个论点;Since another staffed evening is unaffordable 说明无法负担另一个有工作人员值守的晚间时段,使最后的建议顺着问题展开。
  • 语言:attendances(到访人次)、first visits(首次到访)和 additional learners(新增学习者)区分了不同概念。准确区分概念,能让推理更有力。

怎样改进听起来很华丽的句子?

  • The attendance figures irrefutably prove universal educational transformation.The attendance figures show that the room was used during the trial.

    不要把有人使用的证据,变成更广泛成效的证明。 较简短的版本只陈述数据实际支持的内容。

  • The conversation group is valuable. Furthermore, quiet study would replace it.The conversation group is valuable, yet quiet study would replace its only evening session.

    Yet 表达价值与损失之间的矛盾。选择能准确表达观点关系的连接词。

第 1 题无需账户
哪句话在评价论证?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

The trial shows use, but its figures do not measure the cost to existing users.. 第二个选项检验证据,并指出一个遗漏的考虑因素。其他选项只是在转述内容。

第 2 题无需账户
材料记录的到访总数为 36 人次。哪种概括保留了原意?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

The room recorded 36 visits.. Attendances 统计的是到访人次。一个人可以来多次,因此不能把到访人次改写为人数。

第 3 题无需账户
哪项修改最直接地改善组织结构?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

Move the staffing constraint before the proposal that responds to it.. 先交代限制,再提出回应,让推理更容易理解,也把最终建议与产生它的原因联系起来。

编写依据