Spot the mistake

Present perfect continuous error correction: fix eight slips

Try present perfect continuous error correction with eight sentences on helpers, verb forms and stative verbs, with clear examples and feedback.

In short

For present perfect continuous error correction, check have/has + been + -ing and whether the verb describes an activity. Use a simple form for states such as know and for a counted set of completed results.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out

A woman with an umbrella waiting beside a bus shelter on a rainy street.
She has been waiting for the bus. Illustration: Atelier

What does the continuous form tell the listener?

It draws attention to an activity leading up to now. I have been checking the text since Monday can mean the work is still continuing. You are out of breath. Have you been running? describes a recent activity that may have stopped. The present evidence matters, so a finished activity can still take this form. It is the connection to now, rather than a guarantee that the activity is happening this second.

Forms and examples
CheckCorrect exampleReason
AgreementShe has been working.Use has with he, she and it.
Helper chainWe have been waiting.Keep been between have and the -ing form.
ActivityThey have been painting the door.Focus on the process.
ResultThey have painted three doors.Count completed results with the simple.
StateI have known her for years.Know normally takes a simple form.

Can you find the single wrong word?

Each sentence has exactly one word to replace. Keep the meaning in the clue. Some sentences use the simple perfect because they describe a state or count completed results. A duration such as for years can go with either form, so look at the verb and the speaker's focus as well.

Eight repairs

Tap the word that's wrong in each sentence.

  1. She is still at the stop.

  2. Their task is still in progress.

  3. The bus has not arrived.

  4. Your face is red.

  5. His books are still open.

  6. Our friendship began ten years ago.

  7. The activity began on Monday.

  8. All six emails are complete.

Why can both lived and been living be right?

With verbs such as live and work, both forms can describe a situation continuing now. I have lived here for ten years gives the fact; I have been living here for ten years highlights the continuing experience. Neither sentence tells us by itself that the person is about to leave. Check the rest of the conversation before adding that meaning.

Question 1No account needed
Choose the correct answer.Which sentence counts completed results?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

I have read four chapters.. The simple perfect counts four finished chapters; the continuous highlights the activity.

Question 2No account needed
Choose the correct answer.Choose the natural state form.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

We have known her for years.. Know is normally a state verb, and we takes have.

Built from