Updated
Spot the mistake
Whose or who's in everyday messages: ownership, who is and who has in short arrangements
Whose or who's in everyday messages: fix six short questions, test who is and who has, and distinguish an owner from a person arriving or helping.
- A2
- 6 sentences
- Tap the wrong word
- Learn this in the A2 notebook →
In short
Whose asks about ownership: Whose bag is this? Who's means who is or who has: Who's coming? Expand the contraction to check it; the apostrophe does not show possession in whose.
Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out
Are you asking about an owner or an action?
Whose coat is on the chair?
Who owns the coat?
Who's bringing a coat?
Which person is going to bring one?
In the first question, whose goes with a noun. In the second, who's expands to who is, followed by bringing. This contrast is useful in group messages about tickets, food, lifts and things left behind.
Can who's also mean who has?
Yes. Who's taken my pen? means Who has taken my pen? The next word is the past participle taken. Compare Whose pen has Jo taken?: that question asks who owns the pen, while Jo is already named as the person who took it.
Tap the word that's wrong in each sentence.
Ask which friend plans to attend.
Who is coming asks which person will attend; the short form needs an apostrophe.
Ask who owns the bag.
The question asks about the owner of a bag, so use whose before the noun.
Ask which person currently has the spare key.
Who has got asks which person has the key; who's means who has here.
Find out who should cook now.
Whose turn asks which person has the responsibility this time.
Ask which person put the plates here.
The expanded form is who has left, so use the contraction who's.
Ask about the owner of several tickets.
The tickets are already visible; the question asks who owns them.
What if whose is used without a following noun?
The noun can be understood: I found a scarf. Whose is it? This still asks about ownership. Who's it? instead means Who is it? and asks about a person. The expansion test remains useful even when the next word is not an object name.