Reading

B1 English reading: the station piano player: follow two viewpoints in a station encounter

B1 English reading: the station piano player follows an impatient traveller and a musician. Track two viewpoints and explain a changed judgement.

In short

Read how a traveller changes her view of a station musician after asking one question. The story gives two viewpoints; an impatient first impression is not the same as a checked explanation. Rehearsing means practising for a performance.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out

The same four bars

Tara had twenty minutes before her train. She sat near the station piano, hoping to finish a message for work. A young man was playing the same four bars again and again. Each time he reached the high note, he stopped and began again. Tara put on her headphones, but she could still hear him.

“Some people think the whole station is their practice room,” she wrote to her sister. Then she noticed a folded sheet beside the piano: a programme for a concert at the children's hospital. The name at the top was Daniel Price. That made the practice seem less careless, though it did not make it quieter.

Tara stood up. “Excuse me. Are you rehearsing1 for tonight?” she asked. Daniel looked surprised. “For tomorrow,” he said. “My keyboard stopped working this morning. I only need another minute. I cannot quite get this change right.” He showed her the music and played the passage once more, very slowly.

Tara had played the piano as a child. She recognised the awkward stretch. “Could you move your hand before the left note?” she suggested. Daniel tried. The four bars finally became a whole phrase. He laughed, and Tara smiled despite herself.

An announcement interrupted them. Tara's train would leave from a different platform. She closed her work message and lifted her bag. “Thank you,” Daniel said. “For asking before deciding I was showing off.” Tara thought of the text she had sent. “I had already decided a little,” she admitted.

On the platform, she sent her sister another message: “There was more to it. His keyboard broke, and he has a concert tomorrow.” She did not delete the first message. She added the information that had changed her mind. Behind her, the piano had fallen silent.

What changes, and what stays true?

The sound still interrupts Tara's work. New information does not erase that experience. It changes her explanation of Daniel's behaviour: he has a practical problem and a specific goal. Daniel also learns that asking a question can create room for a helpful exchange. The two people have different information before they speak.

Question 1No account needed
Why does Tara first feel annoyed?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

Daniel keeps repeating a short passage.. The repeated four bars interrupt Tara while she is trying to write a work message.

Question 2No account needed
Why is Daniel using the station piano?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

His keyboard stopped working.. He explains that his own keyboard failed that morning, leaving him looking for a place to practise.

Question 3No account needed
What does Tara contribute?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

A suggestion about his hand movement.. Her suggestion helps Daniel play the difficult change as a complete phrase.

Question 4No account needed
Why does she send a second message?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

To add information that corrects her first judgement.. She admits her earlier judgement and adds the facts that changed her understanding.

Built from