Spot the mistake

Dangling participles in English sentences: make the person doing the opening action clear

Dangling participles in English sentences: identify who performs an opening action, correct six unclear subjects and compare short clauses with full ones.

In short

An opening participle phrase usually describes the subject of the main clause: Walking home, Maya saw a fox. If the main subject cannot do the opening action, name the real person or use a full clause.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out

Who is walking, reading or waiting?

Waiting outside, Jo checked the address.

Jo both waited and checked.

Read the words immediately after the comma. They name the person or thing that the opening phrase normally describes. In Walking home, the rain started, the grammar points towards the rain as the walker. That is not the intended meaning. While I was walking home, the rain started clearly names the walker.

Can you make the opening actor clear?

In each item, tap the opening word and expand it into a full while clause. Use the person named in the cue. The repair replaces one word with several words because the two actions have different subjects. Read the whole sentence after the change.

Expand the opening word into a clause with its own subject

Tap the word that's wrong in each sentence.

  1. Maya was walking home when the rain started.

  2. Jo was reading the message when the phone rang.

  3. Sam waited for the bus and felt that time was passing slowly.

  4. Asha was carrying the bags when one handle broke.

  5. Ben was looking at the map when a sign fell.

  6. Leila was listening to the announcement when the lights went out.

When is a full clause better?

Use a full clause when the actions have different subjects: While Jo was checking the map, the bus arrived. Jo checks; the bus arrives. Do not shorten this to Checking the map, the bus arrived. Shorter is not better if it hides who did what.

Compare the patterns
Same person: short form worksDifferent subjects: name both
Opening the cupboard, Jo found the cups.While Jo opened the cupboard, a cup fell.
Waiting outside, we heard the bell.While we waited outside, the bell rang.
Question 1No account needed
Who is holding the bag in Holding the bag, Nina opened the door?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

Nina. The main subject Nina is understood as the person doing the opening action too.

Question 2No account needed
Which sentence names both people clearly?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

While Jo was calling Maya, Sam heard the news.. The full while clause makes Jo the caller and Sam the hearer, preserving different subjects.

Built from