阅读

B2 英语阅读:观点专栏与测验

阅读观点专栏,借助实用释义及有关立场、细节和推断的问题,练习 B2 英语阅读,再检查论证怎样展开。

要点

阅读观点专栏时,先找出作者想改变什么,再检查理由。should 等词表达观点,数字和记录可以提供支持。信心十足的观点并不等于证据。

黄色 核心要点蓝色 重点英语表达红色 注意陷阱

一个人在安静房间里阅读,旁边是共用的小组工作区。
安静房间与小组活动共用空间,呼应作者支持再次试行的条件:provided that,即前提是每个人的意见都得到倾听。 插图:Atelier

先读一遍专栏,了解主旨。再读一遍,找出一句提供证据的话,以及一句说明证据无法告诉我们什么的话。

观点|共用工作空间

Give the quiet room another chance

Our studio's quiet room deserves another trial. After two weeks, some members want to make it permanent; others want the space back for group work. I understand both views. Still, closing it now would be a missed opportunity1. We have learnt enough to ask better questions, even if we have not learnt enough to make a final decision.

The attendance log looks encouraging. Twelve people used the morning sessions and eight used the afternoon sessions. But those figures tell us who came through the door, not what they achieved. Some people simply collected materials. Attendance does not necessarily2 mean better concentration. Calling the trial a complete success would go beyond the evidence3.

Six of the eight afternoon users asked for longer quiet periods. That is a reason to listen, not a reason to speak for the whole studio. Morning users were never asked the same question. Their silence is not opposition4, and it is not agreement either. A fair comparison starts with giving both groups the same chance to answer.

There is also a trade-off5. A room reserved for silent work is a room unavailable for conversation. Group projects matter too. We should protect some shared sessions rather than treat silence as the only useful way to work. A timetable with both options would take more planning, but it would serve different needs.

So I support a second, shorter trial, provided that6 everyone receives the same two questions: what did you come to do, and did the room help? We could also record when people wanted group space and could not find it. On balance7, another trial seems worthwhile8. A permanent room should follow a clearer picture of members' needs, not just an attractive attendance total.

换个简单的说法

The writer wants another trial of the quiet room before the studio makes a final choice.

The room attracted visitors, but the record does not show whether they worked better.

Six afternoon users wanted more quiet time. The studio still needs to ask morning users.

Silent work and group work both need space. The timetable should allow for both.

The next trial should ask everyone the same questions and check the need for group space too.

作者怎样限定主张的范围?

短语虽小,却会改变论证
专栏中的表达作用
Attendance does not necessarily mean better concentration.否认两者必然相连,同时仍保留专注度提高的可能。
Six of the eight afternoon users给出确切人群和人数,而非笼统地说所有人。
provided that everyone receives the same two questions把对再次试行的支持与一个条件联系起来。

试着用两句话回应:I support another trial because ... However, ... 解释观点时,要把作者的建议与附带条件放在一起。

作者希望怎样做,为什么?

第 1 题无需账户
哪句话最能概括作者的主要观点?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

The studio should run another trial with better questions.. 第一段和最后一段都支持先再次试行,再作永久决定。

第 2 题无需账户
出入记录说明了什么?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

Who entered during the trial.. 记录说明谁来过。作者说,有些人只是来取材料。

第 3 题无需账户
作者为什么提到上午的使用者?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

They were not asked the same question.. 缺少上午使用者的回答,使其与下午反馈的比较不完整。

第 4 题无需账户
第四段提到了怎样的取舍?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

Keeping a room silent reduces the space for conversation.. 同一个房间无法同时被预留为安静工作区,又供小组交谈使用。

第 5 题无需账户
最后一段中的 provided that 有什么作用?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

It introduces a condition for the writer's support.. 作者支持再次试行,但条件是每个人都被问到相同的问题。

编写依据