Drill

Past modals practice: must have, can't have, might have

Try past modals practice with must have, can't have and might have. Complete forms and sentences using evidence clues, then check common mistakes.

In short

Use a modal + have + a past participle to give your view of a past event: must have means you feel sure it happened, can't have means you feel sure it did not, and might have means it is possible. Must have gives a conclusion; had to gives a past requirement.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out

A resident checks a parcel and a blank delivery slip at the doorstep.
Must have arrived shows a strong conclusion from the parcel and receipt. Illustration: Atelier

How do you choose must have, can't have or might have?

Your view of what happened
Your meaningPatternExample
I feel sure it happened.must have + past participleThe signed receipt is here. The parcel must have arrived.
I feel sure it did not happen.can't have + past participleThe parcel can't have arrived yesterday: the shop sent it this morning.
Perhaps it happened.might have + past participleThe message might have gone to the old address. Let's check.

These forms describe how certain the speaker feels. Must have is a strong conclusion from clues. Might have leaves other explanations open. In this drill, the hints tell you which meaning to express.

Can you complete these past-modal sentences?

In part 1, add only the past participle. In part 2, write the whole phrase, including the modal and have. In part 3, change the original meaning into a past-modal sentence; use the modal in the hint. Write have in full in your answers.

1 · Which past participle completes the phrase?

  1. The front door is locked and Jo's coat is gone. She must have already. (leave)
  2. This letter was written in 1890. Jo was born in 1995, so she can't have it. (write)
  3. The confirmation is missing. The office might have it to the wrong address. (send)
  4. The lights were off and nobody answered. The office must have closed. (be)
  5. The last folder is still on the desk. Pat can't have it. (take)
  6. Nobody has replied to the invitation. I might have to press Send. (forget)

2 · Which modal phrase matches the hint?

  1. The parcel is here, and the receipt is dated yesterday. It yesterday. (strong positive conclusion; arrive)
  2. The workshop starts at ten. It is only nine, so it yet. (strong negative conclusion; start)
  3. We haven't found the delivery note. Someone it in the wrong folder. (a possible explanation; put)
  4. Ellis answered every question correctly. He the instructions. (strong positive conclusion; understand)
  5. I watched the whole film with Mae. She the ending. (strong negative conclusion; miss)
  6. Ben hasn't received the timetable. We his old email address. (a possible explanation; use)

3 · Can you express the same idea with a past modal?

  1. Original: I'm almost certain the team checked the stock. New: The team the stock. (must; check)
  2. Original: Perhaps the driver left the packs downstairs. New: The driver the packs downstairs. (might; leave)
  3. Original: I'm certain I didn't order those folders. New: I those folders. (can't; order)
  4. Original: Perhaps Maya didn't see the changed date. New: Maya the changed date. (might; not see)
  5. Original: I'm almost certain they went to the other room. New: They to the other room. (must; go)
  6. Original: I'm certain the message didn't reach everyone. New: The message everyone. (can't; reach)

What mistakes change the form or meaning?

  • She must has left.She must have left.

    Use have after a modal, including with he, she and it.

  • They might have went to the wrong room.They might have gone to the wrong room.

    Use the past participle gone after have. Went is the past simple.

  • He can't of received the message.He can't have received the message.

    Write have, not of. In speech, unstressed have can be hard to hear.

  • The rule said we must have checked the cupboard before ordering.The rule said we had to check the cupboard before ordering.

    The rule describes a past requirement. Must have checked would express a conclusion that a check happened.

She might not have seen the message.

Perhaps she did not see it.

Put not before have: might not have seen. This leaves open the possibility that she did see it.

Can you choose the right past-modal meaning?

Question 1No account needed
The signed delivery note confirms that the folders reached the building. Which sentence gives a strong positive conclusion?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

The folders must have arrived.. Must have arrived expresses a strong positive conclusion from the signed note.

Question 2No account needed
You are not sure whether anyone read your message. Which sentence keeps this uncertainty?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

They might have read it.. Might have read means that reading it is one possibility; you are not sure.

Question 3No account needed
Yesterday's written instruction made a stock check compulsory. Which sentence describes that requirement?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

We had to check the stock.. Had to check describes what was required. It does not tell us whether the check happened.

Built from