How do past modals work? Eight rules
1 · What comes after should, could and must?
Use have for every person, then the past participle. Say she must have gone, with have, even after she.
She must have seen the message.The speaker is very sure she saw it.
We should have taken a spare key.Taking one would have been a better choice.
2 · When does should have express regret?
Use should have to look back at a better choice. In this use, the speaker usually means the useful action did not happen. Give the situation so the listener understands.
We didn't check the address. We should have checked it before sending the message.We regret not checking.
3 · What does shouldn't have mean?
Use shouldn't have when an action happened and you think it was a bad choice. It can express your own regret or criticism of someone else.
I shouldn't have sent that reply. It sounded rude.I sent it, and I now think that was a mistake.
You shouldn't have shared her number without asking.You shared it; the speaker criticises that choice.
4 · When is could have a missed chance?
Use could have for an opportunity that was available. Add what actually happened to make the missed chance clear.
We could have called the venue, but we sent an email instead.Calling was an option, but we chose email.
I could have taken the earlier train, but I decided to wait.I had that chance and did not take it.
5 · When is could have an uncertain explanation?
Use could have, might have or may have when something possibly happened and you are unsure. Here, you leave the event open.
The message could have gone to the old address. I haven't checked yet.That is one possible explanation.
The organiser might have missed our email.Perhaps the organiser did not see it.
6 · When does must have show a strong conclusion?
Use must have when the evidence makes a past explanation seem very likely. For a past duty, use had to: We had to check the room means the check was required.
The room is empty and their coats are gone. They must have left.The evidence strongly suggests that they left.
We must have checked the room; here's our signed checklist.The checklist is evidence for the speaker's conclusion.
7 · How do you say a past explanation seems impossible?
Use can't have or couldn't have when you rule out a past explanation. Give the evidence for your conclusion.
She can't have read the reply before lunch. It wasn't sent until two.The timing rules out that explanation.
He couldn't have attended the meeting; he was on a flight at the time.The speaker has a reason to reject that possibility.
8 · Can should have mean that something is expected?
Yes. Should have can describe an expected result by now. You think it has probably happened, but you are waiting to check. It is not always regret.
The parcel should have arrived by now. It was sent on Monday.Arrival is expected, but the speaker has not confirmed it.
