Present perfect or past simple? How to choose, with a time-word test

Present perfect or past simple? Compare finished and unfinished time, recent news and continuing situations, with examples and four quiz questions.

B1Article3 min readIn the B1 notebook →

In short

Use the past simple for an event at a finished past time: I saw her yesterday. Use the present perfect to connect the past with now, for experience, news or a continuing situation: I've lost my keys; I've lived here for five years. A missing time word does not automatically mean present perfect: I opened the door and went in is a past story.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out

A person searches a coat pocket for keys in an open front doorway.
The missing keys are news now; I dropped them on the bus this morning tells the finished story. Illustration: Atelier

How do you know which tense to use?

Look for a time word. A finished, named time points to the past simple. An unfinished time, or no time at all, points to the present perfect. The action can be exactly the same; only the time window changes.

past simplethe window is closed

Focus: a finished time you can name

subject + past form (*went*, *saw*, *worked*)

I saw Priya yesterday.
Yesterday is over.

We moved to Leeds in 2019.
2019 is over.

present perfectthe window is still open

Focus: an unfinished time, or no time at all

subject + *have/has* + past participle

I've seen Priya this week.
This week is not over yet.

We've lived in Leeds for five years.
We still live there.

Which time words go with each tense?

Time words that decide for you
Past simple (finished)Present perfect (open)
yesterdaytoday (while it is still today)
last week, last yearthis week, this year
in 2019, in Mayso far, up to now
two days agoalready, yet, just
when I was a childever, never

Why do people say “I've lost my keys”?

The present perfect is the tense of news and results you can see now. I've lost my keys means the keys are still missing. Once you tell the story with details and a time, switch to the past simple: I dropped them on the bus this morning.

At the front door
  1. Sam

    Have you seen my keys? I've looked everywhere.

    News: the keys are still missing.

  2. You

    No, I haven't. When did you last have them?

    A question about a finished moment.

  3. Sam

    I had them on the bus. I think I dropped them when I got off.

    The story, with a finished time: past simple.

What are the most common mistakes?

  • I have seen him yesterday.I saw him yesterday.

    Yesterday is finished, so it takes the past simple.

  • I live here since 2020.I've lived here since 2020.

    With since and for, an action that is still true takes the present perfect.

  • Did you ever go to Scotland?Have you ever been to Scotland?

    Ever asks about your whole life, an open window. Note been to for a visit.

  • When have you arrived?When did you arrive?

    When asks for a finished time, so the answer and the question use the past simple.

Question 1No account needed
Choose the right form.I ___ my passport at the airport last night.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

left. Last night is a finished, named time, so the past simple left is right.

Question 2No account needed
Choose the right form.She ___ three cups of coffee so far today.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

has drunk. So far today is an open window: today is not over, so use the present perfect.

Question 3No account needed
Which question is correct?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

Have you ever tried haggis?. Ever asks about your whole life, so use have + the past participle tried.

Question 4No account needed
Choose the right form.We ___ in Manchester for ten years, and we still love it.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

have lived. They still live there, and for ten years reaches up to now: present perfect.