Sentence builder

Defining and non-defining relative clauses: when to use commas

Compare defining and non-defining relative clauses, learn when commas change the meaning and rebuild sentences with clear examples and practice.

In short

Use no commas when the clause tells us which person or thing you mean: the desk that Dana borrowed. Use commas when it adds extra information about someone or something already clear: Dana, who borrowed the desk, ... Do not use that in a non-defining clause.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out

Community volunteers move desks together in a bright room.
The volunteers moving desks help picture the volunteers who arrived early. Illustration: Atelier

How do you choose between defining and non-defining clauses?

The volunteers who arrived early moved the desks.This sentence tells us that the early arrivals moved the desks.

Focus: The clause tells us which volunteers. Imagine that others arrived later.

The volunteers who arrived early moved the desks.
No commas: we mean one group of volunteers.

The volunteers, who arrived early, moved the desks.All the volunteers in this group arrived early and moved the desks.

Focus: We already know the group. The clause adds a detail about them.

The volunteers, who arrived early, moved the desks.
Two commas: the arrival time is extra information.

Try taking the clause out. In the first sentence, The volunteers moved the desks loses the detail that selects the early group. In the second, it still names the same group. Choose commas for your meaning, rather than for the length of the sentence.

Can you use which without a comma?

Which and that in British English
JobExampleChoice
Identify a thingThe trolley that Dana borrowed is here.That is correct; no commas.
Identify the same thingThe trolley which Dana borrowed is here.Which is also correct; no commas.
Add a detail about a known thingThe trolley, which belongs to the centre, is here.Use which and commas; that cannot go here.
Identify a personThe volunteer who has the keys is outside.Who is natural; that is also possible in a defining clause.
Add a detail about a named personDana, who has the keys, is outside.Use who and commas; that cannot go here.

Do you need one comma or two?

The side room, which has a screen, is ready.

The extra information sits in the middle, so it needs a comma on each side.

We met in the side room, which has a screen.

The clause comes at the end. The full stop closes the sentence, so there is no second comma.

When can you leave out who, which or that?

In a defining clause, you can leave out the relative word when another person or thing does the action: the trolley Dana borrowed. Dana borrowed the trolley. Keep the relative word when it does the action: the trolley that belongs to the centre. In a non-defining clause, keep it even when it is the object: The trolley, which Dana borrowed yesterday, is here.

Can you build eight sentences with the right commas?

Put the tiles in order. Commas stay attached to their words. The cue tells you whether the description identifies something or adds a detail. Start each sentence with the capital letter.

Build the relative clause

Tap the words in the right order. Tap a placed word to send it back.

  1. Start with The volunteer. Identify the person with the keys.

  2. Start with The trolley. Identify the borrowed trolley.

  3. Start with The room. Identify the north-facing room.

  4. Start with The organiser. Identify the person I emailed; leave out the object relative word.

  5. Start with Dana. We know who Dana is; add the detail about the keys.

  6. Start with This trolley. The trolley is already clear; add its owner.

  7. Start with We chose. Add a detail after the room name.

  8. Start with Beatrice. Add the detail about her work, then say she thanked everyone.

Which relative-clause mistakes should you avoid?

  • Dana, that has the keys, is outside.Dana, who has the keys, is outside.

    Use who for this extra information about Dana. Commas and that do not go together in this relative-clause pattern.

  • This trolley, which belongs to the centre is heavy.This trolley, which belongs to the centre, is heavy.

    The extra detail ends after centre. Close it with a second comma before the main verb is.

  • This is the trolley that Dana borrowed it.This is the trolley that Dana borrowed.

    That already links borrowed to the trolley. Leave out the repeated object it.

  • The trolley belongs to the centre is heavy.The trolley that belongs to the centre is heavy.

    Keep that or which here. The relative word is the subject of belongs.

Question 1No account needed
Several rooms are available. Identify the one with a screen.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

The room that has a screen is upstairs.. The clause identifies one room among several. Use no commas; that is correct here.

Question 2No account needed
Which statement about British English is correct?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

Which can introduce a defining clause without commas.. Which can identify a thing: the trolley which Dana borrowed. This defining use takes no commas.

Question 3No account needed
We already know which centre we mean. Add its opening year.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

Our centre, which opened in 2010, runs evening classes.. The opening year adds information about the known centre. Use which and a comma on each side of the clause.

Question 4No account needed
In which defining clause can you leave out the relative word?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

The trolley that Dana borrowed is heavy.. Dana is the subject of borrowed, so the object relative word can go: The trolley Dana borrowed is heavy.

Built from