Past continuous or past simple? When and while

Compare past continuous or past simple for actions in progress and finished events, with when and while examples, common mistakes and five questions.

A2Article4 min readIn the A2 notebook →

In short

Use the past continuous (was/were + -ing) for an action already happening: I was packing a box when the doorbell rang. Use the past simple for the event: rang. A long action can use the past simple too: I worked all day yesterday.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out

One person packs a box as a visitor arrives at the door.
Sam was packing when the doorbell rang. Illustration: Atelier

When do you use the past continuous?

I was packing a box.The packing was happening at that past moment.

Focus: What was happening then?

person + was/were + -ing

At ten, I was packing a box.
I started before ten. At ten, I was still doing it.

I packed three boxes.I finished packing three boxes.

Focus: What happened?

person + past form

Yesterday I packed three boxes.
This tells us about the finished job.

Think about a moment in the past. At ten, Sam was waiting for a delivery. Then the doorbell rang. The waiting was already happening. The doorbell was a new event. The past continuous tells us what was happening around that event.

Do you use was or were before -ing?

Build the past continuous with was or were
PersonPositiveNegativeQuestion
II was waiting.I wasn't waiting.Was I waiting?
youYou were waiting.You weren't waiting.Were you waiting?
he / she / itShe was waiting.She wasn't waiting.Was she waiting?
weWe were waiting.We weren't waiting.Were we waiting?
you (two or more people)You were waiting.You weren't waiting.Were you waiting?
theyThey were waiting.They weren't waiting.Were they waiting?

Put not after was or were: was not becomes wasn't; were not becomes weren't. In a question, put was or were before the person. Keep the -ing form: What were you doing? Some spellings change: make - making, run - running, lie - lying.

How do you use when and while?

The same delivery, told in three ways
SentenceWhat it shows
I was packing when the doorbell rang.The ringing happened during the packing.
While I was packing, the doorbell rang.The packing was happening when I heard the bell.
The doorbell rang while I was packing.The same two actions, in a different order.

When often introduces the event. While often introduces the action in progress. Choose the tense for the meaning, not just for the word when or while. Put a comma after the first part when it starts with when or while: When the doorbell rang, I was packing.

When I arrived, Sam was making tea.

Sam started making tea before I arrived.

When can come first, followed by a past simple event.

When I arrived, Sam made tea.

I arrived. Then Sam made tea.

Two past simple verbs can show events happening one after the other.

Can two actions both use the past continuous?

While I was packing, Maya was writing the labels.

Both activities were happening at the same time.

Neither activity needs to stop. An event during an activity can also leave it going: I was working when you sent your message. I read it later. For a finished activity, use the past simple even if it took hours: We packed boxes all morning.

Which past continuous mistakes should you check?

  • They was waiting outside.They were waiting outside.

    Use were with they, we and you.

  • I was pack a box.I was packing a box.

    The past continuous needs was/were and an -ing form.

  • Did you were working at ten?Were you working at ten?

    Do not add did to was/were questions. Move were before you.

Question 1No account needed
The packing started at nine and finished at eleven. Complete: At ten, I ___ a box.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

was packing. At ten, the activity was already happening. I takes was: was packing.

Question 2No account needed
Choose the correct sentence about yesterday.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

We were waiting when the van arrived.. We takes were. Add the -ing form waiting for the activity in progress.

Question 3No account needed
You finished all three boxes yesterday. Which sentence says this?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

I packed three boxes yesterday.. Packed presents the completed job. Was packing tells us about the activity, not its completion.

Question 4No account needed
Which question asks about an activity in progress at eight last night?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

What were you doing at eight?. Put were before you, then use doing. The question asks what was happening.

Question 5No account needed
Maya was writing labels from ten to eleven. Sam was packing during that hour too. Choose the correct sentence.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

While Maya was writing labels, Sam was packing.. Both activities were happening at the same time. Each uses was and an -ing form.