Updated
Common mistakes
As long as versus while: conditions and overlapping time
Compare as long as versus while to separate permission with a condition from events happening together, with duration examples and a quick meaning test.
- B2
- 4 corrections
- Examples and fixes
- Learn this in the B2 notebook →
In short
As long as can mean provided that: You can borrow it as long as you return it. It can also describe duration, like for as long as; while usually means during the time that, not provided that.
Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out
- as long as: conditiononly a statement about length of timeprovided that a requirement is met
You can use the room as long as you tidy it afterwards.Tidying afterwards is a condition of using the room.
The tidying happens later, so it is not simply an event happening during room use. You can replace this as long as with provided that. So long as also introduces conditions, though as long as is very common.
- while: overlapping timenormally a condition that must be met laterduring the time when another event happens
I checked the timetable while Jo bought the tickets.The checking and buying happened at overlapping times.
For an ongoing background action, use a form that fits the scene: The phone rang while I was cooking. The word itself does not force the continuous; while Jo bought the tickets is also natural in the right narrative.
- as long as: durationalways conditional permissionfor the whole period that something continues
Keep the coat for as long as you need it.You may keep it throughout the time you need it.
Here the answer concerns length of time. For makes the duration meaning especially clear. In I stayed as long as she stayed, the phrase compares durations. Read the surrounding action before choosing between a time meaning and a condition.
- while: contrastalways two simultaneous actionsa connector contrasting two facts or opinions
The first room is bright, while the second is rather dark.The sentence compares contrasting features.
This use is close to whereas. There may be no event or time period to describe. A contrastive while clause can also begin a sentence: While the room is small, it has plenty of light.
How can you test the meaning?
Try a careful replacement. If provided that keeps the intended relationship, you probably have a condition. If during the time that fits, you have overlapping time. If whereas fits, the relationship is contrast. Some sentences allow more than one reading, so make the requirement or time period explicit when it matters.