更新于
填空
综合多份资料撰写中立结论:分清共识与局限
学习综合多份资料撰写中立结论:完成严谨的综合段落,保留不同研究发现,并区分共同目标与已验证的结果。
- C1
- 5 个空
- 括号内有提示
- 在 C1 学习手册中学习这一点 →
要点
中立的综合结论要说明各份资料共同支持的观点以及尚未解决的问题。对互相冲突的论断要分别归属来源,而不要强行抹平;在目标上达成一致,并不证明所提方法就一定能实现该目标。
黄色 核心要点蓝色 重点英语表达红色 注意陷阱
这两份报告合在一起能支持什么结论?
报告 A 建议延长图书馆开放时间,因为有 12 名受访者希望晚间也能借阅。报告 B 同样支持扩大开放,但记录到上一次延长晚间开放的试行平均每晚只吸引了 4 位读者,并指出晚上 8 点之后没有公共交通。两份报告都没有衡量调整公交时刻表会对到馆人数产生什么影响。
Complete the concluding synthesis
(Both / Neither) reports support the aim of improving access to the library. They differ, however, in the evidence they use to assess later opening. Report A describes expressed demand, (whereas / therefore) Report B records attendance during an earlier trial. These are related but distinct measures: a request for longer hours is not the same as a visit made under the previous transport arrangements.
The findings therefore justify a closer examination of the barriers to evening use rather than a confident prediction about attendance. Report B's transport observation offers a possible (guarantee / explanation) for low participation, but the effect of changing the bus timetable remains untested. (As a consequence / Taken together), the sources support a limited trial in which attendance and transport access are recorded separately.
Such a trial would help distinguish unmet demand from a continuing practical barrier. Until those results are available, the conclusion should remain (unanimous / conditional): later opening may improve access if people can reach and leave the building at the relevant times. The shared aim is clear; the success of this particular combination of changes is not yet established.
哪些动词能让结论保持分寸?
| 动词或短语 | 所表达的论断强度 |
|---|---|
| supports the aim | 该资料赞成这一目标。 |
| reports attendance | 该资料给出了观测到的数量。 |
| suggests an explanation | 该资料提出了一种可能的原因。 |
| establishes an effect | 证据证明了所陈述的结果。 |
避免在结尾作出超出正文综合所能支持的更强论断。Both reports prove that later opening will work 把「支持某个目标」变成了「证明某种结果」。有价值的结论依然可以建议下一步行动,但建议应当说明这一步要检验哪项不确定因素,而不是把不确定因素写成已经解决。