阅读

C1 英语城市主题阅读:观点文章与测验

通过一篇关注日常街道的观点专栏,练习 C1 英语阅读,学习反问、对比和让步,并用问题检验论证。

要点

这篇 C1 观点专栏主张,街道应让人有时间过马路、坐下和相聚。既要看作者的观点,也要看哪些语言使观点有说服力。 concession 指让步,即承认另一种观点中合理的部分;吸引人的图景,并不能证明计划会奏效。

黄色 核心要点蓝色 重点英语表达红色 注意陷阱

英国一处安静的人行横道,有人拄着手杖,附近有张长椅。
街道可以让人有时间过马路、坐下,并 linger,也就是多停留一会儿。 插图:Atelier

观点|找出主要主张及其适用范围

The case for slower cities

At the crossing near my flat, the green figure seems permanently in a hurry. A man with a walking stick starts across; a driver taps the steering wheel. Nobody says anything. The street has already set the pace1.

We have become very good at asking how quickly traffic can move through a place. I would like us to ask a different question: how easily can someone live there? A street is a route, certainly. It is also the space outside a front door, the queue at the bakery, the place where a child learns to ride a bicycle. Why should the first purpose trump2 all the others?

The case for a slower city begins with these ordinary uses. I want crossings that allow an unhurried walk, benches where stopping is welcome and pavements wide enough for two people to talk without blocking everyone else. These are modest ambitions. Their absence, however, tells a forceful story about whose time matters.

Of course, some journeys must be quick. An ambulance needs access; a care worker may have several visits to make; a shop needs deliveries. Any proposal that brushes aside3 these needs deserves to fail. Nor should walking become a test of civic virtue. A person who needs a vehicle should not have to argue for the right to reach their own door.

But accepting those needs does not mean accepting every street as it is. We can protect essential access while questioning how much space we give to vehicles passing through. We can ask when deliveries are needed, where stopping places belong and how a bus passenger reaches the pavement. The useful argument concerns design and trade-offs4, not which group deserves to lose.

Picture a square with a bench in the sun. It is a compelling5 image, and an easy one to put on a campaign leaflet. It also leaves questions unanswered. Can a wheelchair user reach the bench? Where will the delivery van stop? Will traffic simply move to the next street? A drawing cannot settle6 those questions. A carefully designed trial, followed by a review of who benefits and who struggles, would be a better start.

Slower, then, should describe a choice about public space, not a demand that everyone move at the same speed. The point is to give people room to linger7 without making essential journeys harder. Before we celebrate another minute saved at the wheel, let us ask what happens when we arrive. Can we cross? Can we sit? Can we stay? These are everyday freedoms worth taking seriously8.

作者希望你注意街道上的哪些设施?

论证从具体事物出发

专栏怎样让论证更有说服力?

指出修辞手法,再解释效果
专栏原文修辞手法对读者的影响
The street has already set the pace.拟人:赋予事物人的能力街道仿佛决定了谁必须赶路。
Why should the first purpose trump all the others?反问:用问题表达观点引导读者质疑让车辆通行优先的做法。
Of course, some journeys must be quick.让步:承认反方观点中的合理之处先承认紧急出行的需要,再讨论街道可以怎样改变。
We can protect ... We can ask ...平行结构:重复相同的句式把几项实际行动呈现为同一思路的组成部分。
Can we cross? Can we sit? Can we stay?三个简短的平行问句结尾的节奏让人容易记住街道的日常用途。

作者突出日常使用街道的人,也就是 foregrounds 所表达的意思:先关注他们的需要。送货车稍后才在让步段落和关于试行的问题中出现。除了具体选词,顺序和取舍也会影响论证。

你能区分主张、让步和证据吗?

第 1 题无需账户
哪种说法最准确地概括了主要论点?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

Public space should support everyday uses while protecting essential access.. 最后一段把供人停留的空间与必要出行的通行需求结合起来,论点不只是降低速度。

第 2 题无需账户
作者为什么提到救护车、护理员和商店送货?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

To accept important needs that a street plan must address. 这些例子构成让步,先承认合理需要,再回到可能的设计调整。

第 3 题无需账户
阳光下长椅的图景起什么作用?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

It shows an appealing vision that still leaves practical questions.. 作者先说图景吸引人,再提出通行、送货和周边交通等问题。图景有吸引力,不等于有证据证明方案有效。

第 4 题无需账户
最后三个问题有什么效果?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

They make the writer's everyday priorities memorable.. 重复的简短句式突出了过马路、坐下和停留,这些都是作者观点的核心。

第 5 题无需账户
专栏支持哪个结论?

选择一个答案。

答案与解释

The writer proposes a trial and review to test a design.. 试行是作者提出的下一步。文章讨论它应该考察什么,并没有报告已完成试行的结果。

怎样在回应专栏时,公平承认另一方的合理顾虑?

写 100—130 词,谈谈你希望一条熟悉的街道作出什么改变。描述一项具体设施,承认一个合理顾虑,再说明你的建议可以怎样回应。最后提出一个应由试行检验的问题。

Although delivery vehicles need access, a trial could test a separate loading area.

前半部分承认一项需要,后半部分提出可能的应对办法。

使用 although 加分句。不要在主句前再加 but。

检查回应是否兼顾不同需要

这是自我检查工具,不是评分。勾选不会保存。

编写依据