Updated
Dialogue
Questioning assumptions behind a proposal: test the reasoning in a meeting
Questioning assumptions behind a proposal: practise checking evidence, testing alternatives and agreeing a small trial in a workplace dialogue.
- C1
- 14 lines
- Practice mode
- Learn this in the C1 notebook →
In short
Ask which link in the reasoning needs support: What leads us to conclude that longer opening hours would increase attendance? Separate the goal from the proposed method; questioning the method does not mean rejecting the goal.
Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out
The community centre wants more people to use its evening classes. A manager proposes opening every night. You support wider access, but you want to know why this particular change would help. Notice how each question picks up a specific claim instead of calling the entire proposal unrealistic.
- You
I agree that we need to improve access. Could we look at the assumption behind opening every evening?
Support better access, then ask to examine the assumption.
Meaning
You support the goal and identify the reasoning to examine.
- Manager
Certainly. We think people stay away because we close too early.
Meaning
The manager states a possible explanation.
- You
What evidence suggests that closing time is the main barrier?
Ask what supports the claim about closing time.
Meaning
You ask for support for one specific cause.
- Manager
Six people mentioned it in the survey. Others mentioned cost and transport.
Meaning
The evidence points to several possible barriers.
- You
So there is some support, although the responses identify other barriers as well.
Summarise the limited support and the other barriers.
Meaning
You acknowledge the evidence without making it stronger.
- Manager
That's fair. We still need to decide which change to make first.
Meaning
The manager accepts the distinction.
- You
Are we assuming that those six people would attend a later session if we offered one?
Ask whether the proposal assumes actual attendance.
Meaning
You separate a stated preference from future behaviour.
- Manager
Yes. We haven't tested that yet.
Meaning
The manager identifies a gap in the evidence.
- You
Could we test one later evening before changing the whole timetable?
Suggest a limited trial rather than a full change.
Meaning
You suggest a smaller action that would provide information.
- Manager
Possibly. Would one month give us enough information?
Meaning
The manager asks about the trial length.
- You
It could show whether people book, but we should also record how many actually come.
Name two different results to record.
Meaning
You distinguish interest, booking and attendance.
- Manager
Good point. I'll add that distinction to the proposal.
Meaning
The manager agrees to make the reasoning clearer.
- You
Then our next decision is whether the trial is affordable, rather than whether the full change is justified.
State the next decision clearly.
Meaning
You define the narrower decision now being made.
- Manager
Agreed. Let's cost the trial and return to it on Thursday.
Meaning
The meeting finishes with a practical next step.
How do you question the idea without attacking the speaker?
Use What evidence suggests ...? for support, Are we assuming ...? for an unstated step, and Would an alternative ...? for another way forward. This proves nothing dismisses the discussion. This supports a trial, but not yet a permanent change identifies the actual limit and leaves a useful next step.