更新于
对话
质疑提案背后的预设:在会议中检验论证逻辑
在职场对话中练习质疑提案背后的预设,包括核实依据、探讨替代方案,以及就小规模试行达成一致。
- C1
- 14 句台词
- 练习模式
- 在 C1 学习手册中学习这一点 →
要点
询问推理中的哪一环需要依据支持:What leads us to conclude that longer opening hours would increase attendance? 把目标与拟议方法区分开来;质疑方法并不意味着否定目标。
黄色 核心要点蓝色 重点英语表达红色 注意陷阱
社区中心希望更多人参加晚间课程。一位负责人提议每天晚上都开放。你支持扩大参与渠道,但你想知道为什么这项具体改动会有效。注意每一句提问是如何针对具体论断发问,而不是全盘否定整个提案。
- 你
I agree that we need to improve access. Could we look at the assumption behind opening every evening?
表示支持扩大开放,然后请求审视提案背后的预设。
含义
你支持这一目标,并指明需要审视的推理前提。
- Manager
Certainly. We think people stay away because we close too early.
含义
负责人给出了一种可能的解释。
- 你
What evidence suggests that closing time is the main barrier?
询问有什么证据支持关于关门时间的说法。
含义
你针对单一具体原因索要证据支持。
- Manager
Six people mentioned it in the survey. Others mentioned cost and transport.
含义
现有证据指向了多种可能的障碍。
- 你
So there is some support, although the responses identify other barriers as well.
概括有限的证据支持以及其他障碍。
含义
你承认已有依据,但不夸大它的说服力。
- Manager
That's fair. We still need to decide which change to make first.
含义
负责人接受这一区分。
- 你
Are we assuming that those six people would attend a later session if we offered one?
询问提案是否预设了这些人真的会来上课。
含义
你将口头表达的偏好与未来的实际行动区分开。
- Manager
Yes. We haven't tested that yet.
含义
负责人指出了证据中的缺口。
- 你
Could we test one later evening before changing the whole timetable?
建议先进行有限试行,而不是全面调整。
含义
你建议先采取规模较小的行动来获取信息。
- Manager
Possibly. Would one month give us enough information?
含义
负责人询问试行的时长。
- 你
It could show whether people book, but we should also record how many actually come.
说出需要记录的两种不同结果。
含义
你区分了感兴趣、报名预订与实际出席。
- Manager
Good point. I'll add that distinction to the proposal.
含义
负责人同意让论证过程更加清晰。
- 你
Then our next decision is whether the trial is affordable, rather than whether the full change is justified.
清楚地说明接下来的决定是什么。
含义
你界定了当前需要作出的更窄范围的决定。
- Manager
Agreed. Let's cost the trial and return to it on Thursday.
含义
会议以一项切实可行的下一步安排结束。
如何在不针对说话人的情况下质疑某个想法?
用 What evidence suggests ...? 询问证据支持,用 Are we assuming ...? 指出未说明的前提步骤,用 Would an alternative ...? 探讨其他推进方式。This proves nothing 会直接否定讨论;This supports a trial, but not yet a permanent change 则指明了当前的实际界限,并留出了有益的下一步方案。