Scale

Criticism from mild to severe: choose 6 strengths of professional criticism

Choose criticism from mild to severe with six strengths of evaluation, specific examples and a short revision task that keeps evidence and tone aligned.

In short

Criticism can move from a minor weakness to a serious flaw or a fundamental failure. Judge the effect of the problem before choosing the strength of the label. A polite opening does not make an exaggerated judgement accurate.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out

How serious is the criticism?

A problem that defeats the purpose

  1. a fundamental failurea breakdown in the central purpose or requirementThe system's failure to record any bookings is a fundamental failure of the service.
  2. a fundamental problema difficulty in the basic design or reasoningThere is a fundamental problem with the way the groups were selected.
  3. a serious flawa major defect that threatens the resultThe untested assumption is a serious flaw in the forecast.
  4. a significant weaknessa problem that materially reduces qualityThe missing comparison is a significant weakness in the analysis.
  5. an area for improvementsomething that could work betterThe signposting is an area for improvement, although the argument is clear.
  6. a minor weaknessa limited problem with a small effectThere is a minor weakness in the opening example.

A small, local weakness

What evidence supports a strong judgement?

The steps are a guide to typical force, not fixed grades. An area for improvement can be a gentle way to raise a large issue, so add the actual effect. Fundamental concerns the foundation of a plan or argument; it does not just mean that you dislike it strongly. Name the feature, explain its consequence and say what would count as a repair.

Keep the judgement proportionate
Observed problemMeasured wording
One caption has the wrong date.One caption needs correcting.
The report omits the largest cost category.The cost estimate has a serious omission.
The sample excludes the group named in the research question.The design has a fundamental problem of relevance.

The comparison is a significant weakness because it uses different time periods.

The reason explains why the weakness changes the value of the comparison.

How can you criticise work without judging the person?

Use the work as the grammatical subject: The explanation leaves the final step unclear. Avoid turning one defect into a judgement of character: You are careless. A focused sentence makes revision possible. You can still be direct: This version cannot be approved because the figures do not add up. Directness and respect can work together when the reason and next action are explicit.

Question 1No account needed
A report is sound except for one misspelt name. Which comment fits?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

There is a small error in one name.. A local spelling error calls for a local correction, not rejection of the whole report.

Question 2No account needed
Which sentence gives a repairable criticism?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

The method is unclear about who was interviewed.. It names the missing information, so the writer knows what to clarify.

Built from