Ellipsis and substitution: so do I, I hope so, I'd rather not

Learn ellipsis and substitution with so do I, neither can I, I hope so and I'd rather not, then compare short replies and practise eight matching pairs.

C1Article6 min readIn the C1 notebook →

In short

English speakers shorten repeated ideas with words the listener can easily recover: I can help. - So can I. Ellipsis leaves words out, while substitution uses a word such as so or one in their place; keep the full phrase when a short reply could refer to two different things.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out

Two friends share a conversation over cups in a rainy high-street café.
In conversation, So do I keeps a shared idea brief. Illustration: Atelier

What is the difference between ellipsis and substitution?

What is understood but not repeated?
Full ideaShort versionHow it works
Mina has checked the list, but Leo has not checked the list.Mina has checked the list, but Leo has not.Ellipsis: checked the list is left out.
Will the room be free? I hope the room will be free.Will the room be free? I hope so.Substitution: so stands for the hoped-for situation.
I need a pen. Have you got a spare pen?I need a pen. Have you got a spare one?Substitution: one replaces the countable noun pen.
Would you like to chair the meeting? I'd rather not chair it.Would you like to chair the meeting? I'd rather not.Ellipsis: chair the meeting is understood.

The names describe two ways of avoiding repetition. Start with the meaning: can the listener supply the missing words from what has just been said? Then choose the form that fits the grammar.

When do you say so do I or neither do I?

Use so + auxiliary + subject to say that a positive statement is also true for another person. Use neither or nor for a negative statement. Match the auxiliary to the earlier verb and make it agree with the new subject.

Choose the helper verb
First speakerAgreeing replyUnderstood meaning
I work from home.So do I.I work from home too.
I enjoyed the lecture.So did I.I enjoyed it too.
I'm looking forward to it.So am I.I'm looking forward to it too.
I've already booked.So has Priya.Priya has already booked too.
I can stay.So can we.We can stay too.
I don't drive.Neither do I.I don't drive either.
I haven't finished.Neither have I.I haven't finished either.
I wouldn't accept that offer.Nor would I.I wouldn't accept it either.

With an ordinary present or past verb, supply do, does or did. With be, have as a perfect auxiliary, or a modal such as can, keep that helper. For a possession statement with lexical have, I have a bike - So do I is a useful pattern; with I've got a bike, use So have I.

Two different uses of so
  1. Ruth

    I work on Saturdays.

    Ruth describes her routine.

  2. Jo

    So do I.

    Jo also works on Saturdays.

  3. Ruth

    You've still got my notebook.

    Ruth reminds Jo about something.

  4. Jo

    So I have! I'll bring it tomorrow.

    Jo realises Ruth is right.

So do I and So I do have different jobs. In So do I, the statement is also true for me. In So I do!, I recognise or confirm a fact about myself, often with surprise: You know her brother. - So I do!

When do you use I hope so and I hope not?

Short replies about a whole situation
QuestionReplyMeaning
Will they accept the proposal?I hope so.I want them to accept it.
Will the train be cancelled?I hope not.I want it to run.
Is the library open?I think so.I believe it is open.
Has the deadline changed?I don't think so.I believe it has stayed the same.
Will we need to pay again?I'm afraid so.Yes, unfortunately.

For a negative hope, the usual reply is I hope not. For a negative belief, I don't think so is common in conversation; I think not sounds more formal. Learn these as whole replies rather than moving not into the same position every time.

Why do you say I'd rather not, with no to?

'Would you like to lead the discussion?' 'I'd rather not, if that's all right.'

I would prefer not to lead it.

Would rather takes a base verb: I'd rather wait. A negative preference is I'd rather not wait. When the action is already clear, leave it out: I'd rather not. I'd prefer not to is another natural short refusal; it keeps to because prefer uses a different pattern.

  • I'm tired. - So do I.I'm tired. - So am I.

    Match am, a form of be. The first statement has no ordinary action verb needing do.

  • I can't stay. - So can I.I can't stay. - Neither can I.

    The first statement is negative. Use neither can I to share that negative meaning.

  • I'd rather not to.I'd rather not.

    Would rather takes a base verb, with no to. The understood action can be left out.

When can do so, one and ones replace repeated words?

Please upload the revised list. If you can't do so today, let me know.

Here, do so means upload the revised list.

Do so points to an action already mentioned. It often suits instructions and written replies. In conversation, I'll do it after lunch may be a more direct answer about a particular task. With a state, keep the helper instead: Leo knows the code, and Mina does too.

This chair is broken. Use the one by the window. The blue ones are reserved.

One means chair; ones means chairs.

Use one and ones for countable things. For an amount word, use a quantity expression: Do you need paper? I've got some. Learn some here rather than trying to replace paper with one.

When should you repeat the full meaning?

Suppose someone says, Please check the figures and email the client. The reply I'll do so this afternoon will usually cover both actions. If you mean only the email, say I'll email the client this afternoon. Repeat the useful detail wherever two interpretations are possible.

Which short reply fits each situation?

Tap one on the left, then its partner on the right.

Question 1No account needed
'I've finished the report.' Say that Priya has finished too.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

So has Priya.. The first speaker uses the present perfect. Keep has for the new subject, Priya.

Question 2No account needed
'You still owe me a pound.' Recognise a fact you had forgotten.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

So I do!. So I do! confirms a fact about yourself. So do I would add another person with the same situation.

Question 3No account needed
Which is the usual short reply when you want the train to run?'Will the train be cancelled?'

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

I hope not.. I hope not means you hope the cancellation will not happen.

Question 4No account needed
Which reply completes the exchange naturally?'Would you rather wait outside?' 'No, I'd rather ___.'

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

not. I'd rather not leaves out the understood action, wait outside. There is no to after rather.

Question 5No account needed
You have been asked to check the figures and email the client. You intend to email only. Which reply is clearest?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

I'll email the client this afternoon.. Repeating email the client identifies the one action you intend to take.