Graded story

B1 English short story: the letter in the attic

Read a B1 English short story about a Yorkshire family mystery, an old letter and a secret, with eight glosses, past perfect and reading questions.

What will you practise?

An old letter changes what Ella knows about her grandmother. Follow what happened first: had hidden points to a time before Ella found the letter. Do not use the past perfect for every event; use the past simple to move the story forward.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out

A woman finds a letter and photograph in a wooden box in a rainy attic.
The old letter reveals what Alice had hidden years earlier. Illustration: Atelier

A house in Yorkshire

The letter in the attic

Rain was beating against the windows of her grandmother's house in Yorkshire. Ella was helping to clear the attic1 when she found a small wooden box behind a suitcase. Inside lay a photograph, a dried flower and an envelope2 addressed to Alice, her grandmother.

Someone had opened the letter before. Ella carefully unfolded3 the paper. It was dated 1962.

"Dear Alice, I arrived in London yesterday. The room is tiny, but I can practise my violin here. Your money paid for the train ticket. Please keep this letter somewhere safe. Dad mustn't find out you've helped me. Your loving sister, Rose."

Ella read the last line twice. Her grandmother had always said she was an only child4. Yet the girl in the photograph had Alice's eyes. On the back, someone had written two names: Alice and Rose.

Downstairs, Alice was making tea. When Ella put the photograph on the table, her grandmother stopped pouring.

"Where did you find that?"

"In the attic. Who's Rose?"

For a moment, Alice watched the rain. Then she sat down.

"My younger sister. Our father wanted her to stay and work in his shop. She wanted to play music. I had saved a little money, so I sent it to her."

"Why didn't you tell us?"

"At first, I was afraid of upsetting5 Dad. Later, I didn't know how to begin. Rose and I lost touch6 after she moved again. I had hidden the letter so well that I forgot where it was."

Ella looked at the photograph. All those years, the answer had been upstairs.

"We could try to find her," she said.

Alice nodded7. "There's one thing I remember. She played in a little orchestra in Leeds."

Ella reached for her phone. The tea had gone cold8, but neither of them noticed.

In simpler words

It is raining. Ella finds a box in her grandmother's attic. There is a letter to her grandmother, Alice, inside.

The letter is already open. Ella opens out the paper and sees the date: 1962.

Rose writes that she has arrived in London. Alice sent her money for the train. Rose asks Alice to keep their secret.

Ella is surprised. Alice said she had no brothers or sisters. The photograph shows Alice and Rose together.

Alice is making tea. She stops when she sees the photograph.

Alice asks where Ella found the photograph.

Ella says it was in the attic and asks about Rose.

Alice is quiet, then sits down.

Alice says Rose is her younger sister. Rose wanted to be a musician, but their father wanted her to work in his shop. Alice helped Rose with money.

Ella asks why Alice kept this secret.

Alice was worried about her father's feelings. Later, it became hard to talk about Rose. The sisters stopped speaking, and Alice forgot where she had put the letter.

The letter was in the attic for many years.

Ella suggests looking for Rose.

Alice agrees. She remembers that Rose played music in Leeds.

Ella gets her phone to start looking. They are too interested to notice their cold tea.

Which objects help you follow the mystery?

Find the objects from the story

How does the past perfect show what happened first?

Earlier event and later event
Story sentenceFirstLater
Someone had opened the letter before Ella found it.Someone opened the letter.Ella found it.
Alice had saved some money before she sent it to Rose.Alice saved money.Alice sent the money.
Alice had hidden the letter before Ella discovered it.Alice hid the letter.Ella discovered it.

Make the past perfect with had + past participle: had saved, had hidden, had gone. The form is the same with I, she and they. Once the order is clear, the past simple can tell the next events: Ella read the letter. She went downstairs.

  • Alice had hide the letter.Alice had hidden the letter.

    Use the past participle hidden after had. The three forms are hide - hid - hidden.

  • Ella didn't knew about Rose.Ella didn't know about Rose.

    Use the base form after didn't. Didn't already shows past time, so write know, not knew.

Did you understand the letter and the secret?

Question 1No account needed
Why is Ella surprised by the words 'Your loving sister'?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

Alice had told her she had no brothers or sisters.. Alice had said she was an only child. The letter and the two names on the photograph tell a different story.

Question 2No account needed
What had Alice done before Rose travelled to London?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

She had sent Rose some money.. Rose used Alice's money to buy the train ticket. The letter says she arrived in London the day before she wrote it.

Question 3No account needed
What happened to the sisters after Rose moved again?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

They stopped keeping in touch.. Alice says they lost touch. This means they stopped writing, calling or seeing each other.

Question 4No account needed
Which event happened first in 'Alice had hidden the letter before Ella discovered it'?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

Alice hid the letter.. Had hidden places Alice's action before Ella's discovery. The past perfect shows the earlier event.

How could you continue the story?

Write 60-80 words about Ella's first phone call to the orchestra. Who answers? What do they remember about Rose? Include one earlier event with had + past participle, then use the past simple for the next events.

Built from