Sorting game

Would rather or had rather: sort modern preferences and dated literary forms

Sort would rather or had rather forms by modern and literary use, decode I'd rather correctly, and practise preferences about your own or another action.

In short

For a preference in modern British English, use would rather: I would rather walk. The older form had rather is less common and sounds old-fashioned; I'd rather normally means I would rather. Do not confuse would rather with had better, which gives strong advice.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out

Which preference forms sound normal today?

Modern preference or older literary form?

Tap a word, then the box it belongs in.

What comes after would rather?

Two useful modern patterns
Whose action?PatternExample
Your own actionwould rather + plain verbI'd rather stay at home.
Another person's actionwould rather + subject + past formI'd rather you stayed at home.
Your own negative actionwould rather not + plain verbI'd rather not drive tonight.

The past form in I'd rather you stayed refers to a preference about now or the future, rather than a completed past event. Keep a clear subject after rather when another person will do the action. Compare I'd rather leave with I'd rather you left. The first names my preferred action; the second states a preference about yours.

I would rather wait than pay for a taxi.

Waiting is the preferred choice.

You had better leave means leaving is advisable, often because there may be a problem if you stay. It does not simply compare two choices. In writing, expand I'd if the full form is the point you need to explain. A dated form can be meaningful in a novel without being the best model for a new workplace conversation.

Question 1No account needed
What does I'd normally stand for in I'd rather wait?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

I would. The normal modern preference construction is I would rather wait.

Question 2No account needed
Which sentence asks for someone else's action?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

I'd rather you called tomorrow.. The subject you shows that the preferred action belongs to the other person.

Built from