Graded story

B1 English reading: The quiet carriage dispute – read a request and an implied complaint

B1 English reading: The quiet carriage dispute follows a loud call, an indirect complaint and a clear request, with glosses and four questions.

In short

The story contrasts a clear request with an indirect complaint. Could you lower your voice? names an action; a remark about other passengers may express criticism without stating exactly what should change.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out

Read, then answer the questions

A quieter sentence

The train was nearly full when Rob found a seat in the quiet carriage. A sign by the door asked passengers to keep noise low. He put his laptop on the table and began preparing a report. Across the aisle, a man in a grey coat answered his phone.

At first, the call was short. Then the man began explaining a problem at work, repeating the same figures more loudly each time. Rob stopped typing. He looked up and said, 'Some of us have work to do.' The man glanced at him but continued talking. Perhaps he had not understood the remark; perhaps he thought his own work was just as important.

A woman beside the window closed her book. 'Excuse me,' she said. 'Could you lower your voice, please? We can hear the whole call.' The man paused1, looked at the sign and stood up. 'Sorry. I'll finish it by the doors.' He moved into the vestibule2, away from the seats.

Rob went back to his report. After a minute, he turned to the woman. 'I thought I'd already asked him to stop.' She smiled. 'I heard that you were annoyed. I wasn't sure what you wanted him to do.' Rob looked at his unfinished sentence on the screen. He had made his criticism clear, but not his request3.

When the man returned, he put his phone away. 'I didn't notice the sign when I sat down,' he said. Rob nodded. 'Thanks for moving.' The woman opened her book again. The carriage was still not silent: wheels rattled and a child whispered to a parent further down. But everyone at their table could concentrate4 again.

Which words tell the man what to change?

Question 1No account needed
What does Rob's first remark clearly show?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

He is annoyed by the call.. Looking up and saying some people have work to do expresses annoyance in this context.

Question 2No account needed
Which phrase names a specific action?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

Could you lower your voice, please?. Lower your voice tells the listener exactly what change is being requested.

Question 3No account needed
Does the story tell us why the man ignores Rob at first?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

No, it offers possibilities rather than a settled reason.. The narrator says perhaps twice and does not claim to know the man's first interpretation.

Question 4No account needed
What happens after the clear request?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

The man moves to finish his call by the doors.. The man apologises and moves to the vestibule to finish the call.

Built from