The subjunctive in English: I suggest he be

Learn the subjunctive in English after suggestions and demands, were for unreal situations and fixed phrases, with examples and practice questions.

C1Article6 min readIn the C1 notebook →

In short

After a formal suggestion, demand or statement of need, use the base verb for every subject: I suggest he be present; we requested that she attend. British English also uses should: I suggest he should be present. The proposal is not a statement that it is already true; unreal were and phrases such as so be it are other uses of the subjunctive.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out

A small group listens as one person suggests an idea around a meeting table.
The group considers a proposal: I suggest that we remain open. Illustration: Atelier

Why does a formal suggestion use 'he be'?

The name mandative subjunctive describes a form used for something someone wants to happen. It often follows suggest, recommend, request, demand or insist. The base form is the verb as you find it in a dictionary: be, go, remain. It stays the same after I, she, we and other subjects.

Proposed action, not a report of an event
PatternExampleWhat the speaker wants
suggest / recommend + thatI suggest that he be invited.Invite him.
request / demand + thatThey requested that she attend the review.Ask her to come.
insist + thatThe chair insisted that everyone remain seated.Keep everyone in their seats.
It is essential / vital + thatIt is essential that each member have a copy.Give a copy to every member.
a recommendation + thatWe accepted the recommendation that the group remain open.Keep the group open.

In each member have, there is no -s. In he be, the verb is not is. You can leave out that after some verbs: I suggest he be invited. Keeping that often makes a long formal sentence easier to follow.

How do you make a negative, a passive or a past report?

The form stays simple even in a longer sentence
UseExampleNotice
NegativeWe ask that visitors not enter the room.Put not before the base verb; there is no do or does.
PassiveThey recommended that the notice be rewritten.Use be + past participle.
Past reporting verbShe recommended that he join the group.Recommended is past; join stays in the base form.
Past reporting verb with beThe chair requested that the door be kept open.Be stays be after requested.

The coordinator requested that the rota not be changed until Friday.

The coordinator wanted people to keep the same rota until Friday.

Not comes before be, and changed is the past participle. The past reporting verb does not turn be into was.

Is 'should be' also correct in British English?

Yes. Both forms are standard in British English. The base-form subjunctive is common in formal writing, minutes and official requests. The should pattern is also natural: They recommended that the notice should be rewritten. In a conversation, a shorter pattern may work well: I suggest inviting him.

Choosing a timetable
  1. Chair

    I suggest that the group remain open on Thursdays.

    The chair proposes a Thursday session.

  2. Coordinator

    I'd recommend that we should review the rota after four weeks.

    The coordinator offers another formal recommendation.

  3. Learner representative

    Could we try alternating Tuesdays and Thursdays?

    A direct question gives a less formal way to propose a plan.

  4. Chair

    Let's compare the options before we decide.

    The proposals are still being discussed.

Does 'insist' or 'suggest' always take the subjunctive?

She insists that he is ready.She strongly says this is true.

Focus: a statement of fact, according to her

She insists that he is ready.
She says he is ready now.

She insists that he be ready by nine.She demands that he prepare in time.

Focus: a demand about what should happen

She insists that he be ready by nine.
She wants him to be ready at nine.

The meaning decides the pattern. The figures suggest that demand is falling means the figures give us a reason to think this is happening. I suggest that we reduce the price proposes an action. Do not change every verb after suggest into a base form.

When do you use 'were' for an unreal situation?

For an imagined situation now or in the future, formal English uses were even after I, he, she and it. This is often called the past subjunctive or irrealis were. It shows distance from reality, rather than past time.

Unreal situations and real questions
ExampleMeaning
If I were chair, I would ask for another vote.I am not chair; this is my imagined action.
I wish the timetable were more flexible.I want a different timetable now.
Were the room to close, we would meet online.Formal: if the room closed in the future.
If she was at the meeting yesterday, she heard the announcement.We do not know whether she was there; this is a real possibility about the past.
I wish I had been at the meeting.I regret missing a past meeting.

You will also hear if I was in informal unreal conditions. If I were is a useful choice in careful formal writing. For regret about an earlier event, use the past perfect: I wish I had been there.

What do 'so be it' and 'come what may' mean?

Learn these as whole phrases
Phrase in a sentenceMeaningWhere it fits
If that is the final decision, so be it.I accept it, although I may dislike it.A firm response; it can sound resigned.
Be that as it may, we still need a decision.That may be true, but my next point still matters.Formal discussion; it can sound dismissive.
Come what may, we will finish the work.Whatever happens, we will finish.A strong promise or determination.
Long live the King!A wish for the King's long life.A ceremonial expression.
  • We request that she be gave a copy.We request that she be given a copy.

    The passive uses be + past participle: be given. Gave is the past simple, so it cannot follow be here.

  • They recommended that he to attend.They recommended that he attend.

    There is no to in this subjunctive pattern: recommend that + subject + base verb.

  • It is vital that he doesn't be late.It is vital that he not be late.

    A negative subjunctive uses not + base verb. You can also say It is vital that he should not be late.

Question 1No account needed
Complete this formal request using the subjunctive.We request that every applicant ___ given the same information.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

be. The subjunctive passive is be given. It stays the same after every applicant.

Question 2No account needed
Complete the negative subjunctive.The chair asked that members ___ the draft yet.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

not circulate. Use not before the base form circulate. The past reporting verb asked does not change that form.

Question 3No account needed
Complete the formal recommendation using the subjunctive.Yesterday, the panel recommended that he ___ the team next month.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

join. Recommended that can take the base form join. The recommendation was made yesterday; the proposed action is next month.

Question 4No account needed
Choose the careful formal version of this unreal condition.If I ___ responsible for the rota, I would change it.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

were. Were presents an imagined situation now. Would change gives the result in that imagined situation.

Question 5No account needed
What does this sentence mean?She insists that the figures are accurate.

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

She strongly says the figures are correct.. Insists that the figures are accurate reports her strong statement about a fact, rather than a demand for action.