Scale

Money adjectives: thrifty to stingy with examples

Compare money adjectives from thrifty and frugal to penny-pinching and stingy, with a seven-step scale, examples and questions on praise and criticism.

In short

Thrifty usually praises sensible saving; stingy criticises an unwillingness to spend or give. The word shows your judgement as well as the spending habit. Having little money is not the same as being stingy.

Yellow the idea to rememberBlue English to learnRed watch out

Someone mends a coat at a kitchen table with a small coin jar nearby.
Mending an old coat can be a thrifty choice. Illustration: Atelier

Which words praise saving, and which words criticise it?

Read the scale from praise towards criticism. The first three descriptions can all be approving. This is a change in judgement, not an exact order of spending. The words overlap: tight-fisted and stingy, for example, have no fixed order of strength. Context decides how harsh they sound. Frugal focuses on a simple way of living; thrifty focuses on making good use of money.

From sensible saving to an unwillingness to spend

Strong criticism

  1. miserlyextremely unwilling to spend or give moneyStrong criticism: The wealthy owner offered a miserly sum for a full day's work. It can describe a person, payment or amount.
  2. stingyunwilling to spend, give or share enoughDirect criticism: It was stingy of them to ask volunteers to pay for their own tea. Also used in stingy with praise.
  3. tight-fistedvery unwilling to spend money or give it to othersInformal criticism: He's too tight-fisted to buy a round, even when everyone else has bought one.
  4. penny-pinchingtrying to save very small amounts in a way that causes problemsDisapproving: The penny-pinching decision to cut cleaning hours left the rooms dirty. Often used about decisions or organisations.
  5. careful with moneythinking before spending and keeping costs under controlUsually neutral or gently approving: I'm careful with money, but I enjoy treating my friends.
  6. frugalliving simply and spending very littleOften approving or neutral: They lead a frugal life, with few luxuries. It can describe a choice or a response to limited money.
  7. thriftyusing money carefully and avoiding wasteUsually praise: She's thrifty: she repairs things and saves for what matters.

Approval

Can the same action sound sensible or mean?

Actions and judgements
What happenedA speaker's descriptionWhat the description adds
Alex repaired an old coat rather than buying a new one.Alex is thrifty.The speaker admires the choice.
Alex keeps spending on clothes very low.Alex is frugal.The speaker notices a simple lifestyle.
Alex refused to contribute to a shared leaving present despite being able to afford it.Alex is stingy.The speaker thinks Alex should have given something.
The office saved a little by removing all the spare chairs.That was penny-pinching.The speaker thinks the saving caused an unnecessary problem.

Separate the action from the judgement. She spent two pounds gives an amount. She was stingy adds the speaker's view that she should have spent or given more. In a report, name the action first so readers can judge it for themselves.

Which patterns go with stingy, mean and economical?

He was stingy with tips, even when the service was excellent.

He gave staff very little extra money.

It was mean of him to charge his sister for a cup of tea.

Here, mean criticises an ungenerous action.

This car is economical to run.

It costs relatively little to use.

In British English, mean can mean unwilling to spend or share, as well as unkind more generally. Economical usually describes something that uses little money, fuel or other resources. For a person, careful with money is clearer. Calling someone stingy is a personal criticism; it is much sharper than asking to discuss a budget.

Which word fits the speaker's attitude?

Question 1No account needed
You admire Jo for repairing clothes and avoiding waste. Which word best expresses that praise?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

thrifty. Thrifty usually praises careful spending and avoiding waste. The other two words criticise.

Question 2No account needed
A manager saves a tiny amount by removing a service that staff need. Which description targets that harmful saving?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

a penny-pinching decision. Penny-pinching criticises small savings made at an unreasonable cost to people or quality.

Question 3No account needed
A letter says, 'The employer offered a miserly payment.' What is the writer's view?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

The payment was far too small.. Miserly strongly criticises the amount offered. It says nothing about when the money arrived.

Question 4No account needed
Which sentence gives an action that a reader can check, rather than judging someone's character?

Choose one answer.

Answer and explanation

She declined to contribute to the collection.. Declined to contribute states an action. The other descriptions add a negative judgement of the person.

Built from